An Explanation for “Liberal Guilt”

|

There was an interesting article in the Wall Street Journal this morning. Residents of affluent school districts in Kansas have sued to overturn state rules that limit their ability to raise taxes and increase school spending. “Kansas is one of a handful of states that limit how much money local school districts can raise from property taxes—a restriction to ensure a rough parity in spending across the state,” according to this source. “Lawyers for Kansas Republican Gov. Sam Brownback noted that parents can spend as much as they want on their children's education through private tutors. But courts in Kansas and across the U.S. have repeatedly held that states have an obligation to ensure equity—or at least, get as close as possible—at public schools…The state's position has drawn strong support from parents and school administrators in poor districts across Kansas.”

While only a handful of states have the same limitations as Kansas, most states have much more equal school financing than New York. In many southern states, in fact, school districts cover entire counties while in the Midwest states cover a much larger part of the school bill. Tabulations of school spending inequality that I have read, ironically, always have the true Blue States of the Northeast and West coasts with the most unequal school funding, and the Red States with the least. Perhaps that explains “liberal guilt.” The liberals are guilty, and in the past used to feel that way.

Uncategorized

The Gateway (Boogie Ooogie Ooogie-ing at Bar Great Harry While Remembering Ruby’s Edition)

|

I believe that in 1978, the year of Elvis Costello and the Cars, the Best New Artist was Taste of Honey (remember "Boogie Oogie Oogie"); the Clash and the Pistols weren't even nominated. Then there was the year the Best Rock and Roll recording was "The Alley Cat."

Folks, if you watch the Grammys for anything but gawking purposes (and the inadvertent good performance), you've probably missed the point

 

 

Uncategorized

UFT ad blasts Bloomberg

|

“Mayor Bloomberg sees things differently than the rest of us. Our schools are short of money. Yet he refuses to ask millionaires to pay their fair share. He says class size doesn’t matter.”

That’s how the teachers’ union starts it's new TV ad attacking Mayor Bloomberg for pushing to repeal the “Last In/First Out” state law that requires teachers be laid off based on seniority rather than merit during a budget crisis.

Uncategorized

The Myth Of Main Street Moderate

|

A few pundits and others in the press have decided that moderate Republicans are making a comeback.

 

They have decided this true because the number of Republican Senators & Congressmen who are members of the self-declared centrist group, the Republican Main Street Partnership has grown.

 

Here’s the Political Fix blog of the Washington Post –

 

Uncategorized

Bloomberg’s Pension Proposals

|

At this point, I almost feel that everyone who might ever take a look at Room Eight either knows what I would think about things, or is willfully not dealing with the issues I raise. But in case someone is merely dense, here once again is what I think of Mayor Bloomberg’s pension proposals. Any difference in total compensation, the sum of wages, pensions and other benefits, between older and younger generations of public employees represents a social injustice – and/or a reduction in the future quality of public services. The only question is the nature of that injustice, who benefitted from it, who will lose (or has lost), and how. Therefore, any change in pension benefits for future employees should be offset, dollar for dollar, by higher cash pay for those employees, or higher pension contributions for existing employees.

That is not what is being proposed. What we have is yet another cycle of screw the newbie, flee to Florida, with older generations passing retroactive pension enhancements for themselves on their way out the door, and then hitting younger generations of public employees with lower wages and benefits and the New Yorkers who remain here with diminished public services at higher tax rates. Mayor Bloomberg claimed he was different. But he has exactly replicated the policies of New York’s machine pols, to the detriment of the city’s future, because that was and is the path of least resistance in the era of Generation Greed.

Uncategorized

The Cost of that New Jersey Tunnel

|

Amtrak is estimating it will take 10 years and $13.5 billion dollars to complete the New Jersey to New York tunnel it has just proposed, along with improvements between Newark and the tunnel entrance. This project would replace ARC, another tunnel originally expected to cost around $9 billion but with escalating costs due to expected overruns.

But according to Wikipedia, the Pennsylvania Railroad built the existing two track tunnel under the Hudson from New Jersey to New York City, plus the four tracks under the East River from the Sunnyside Yard to New York City, electrified the whole system, and built the original Penn Station from 1903 to 1910 for a fraction of the cost. “The total project cost to the Pennsylvania Railroad for the station and associated tunnels was $114 million (approximately $2.5 billion in 2007 dollars), according to an Interstate Commerce Commission report. (John A. Droege, Passenger Terminals and Trains. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1916) Without tunnel boring machines or any of the construction equipment that has been developed in the past 100 years. THAT IS THE PROBLEM. And by the way, I checked the inflation adjustment, and it is correct. Just $2.5 billion.

Uncategorized

Questions Not Asked

|

Why are municipalities that have higher median incomes, lower poverty rates or both proposed to get AIM aid from the State of New York, while the City of New York gets none? No, the excuse in the Cuomo budget presentation, that New York City doesn’t need AIM because it has lots of taxes, doesn’t cut it. Other places could have personal income taxes too. Yonkers, for one, has had such taxes. Is it because local governments in the rest of the state have added employees over 20 years, while New York City has reduced employees?

And given that the State of New York is broke, why can’t Mayor Bloomberg ask that municipalities that do not have median incomes that are lower than New York City, or poverty rates that are higher, have their AIM aid eliminated too, to save money and reduce other cuts? Wouldn’t that also be equitable, and not make the state’s budget problems worse?

Uncategorized
© Room Eight