Just When You Thought it Was Safe to Go Back on Room 8

I’ll do anything to avoid compiling the proof that I’m not JP, so here’s another “The Gate-Way” archive–this one from March 2010.

Not all partisanship is mindless

Defiance | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 1

Will my friends on the left stop using the words Israel and apartheid in the same sentence? Will my friends on the Zionist right stop calling Richard Cohen anti-Israel?

Richard Cohen – Israel has its faults, but apartheid isn't one of them – washingtonpost.com

www.washingtonpost.com

March 2

Why do people who claim to want to help the poor (Bart Stupak and the Bishops) want to kill health care over a lie?

The Senate bill doesn't fund abortions. Here's why Stupak thinks it does. – By Timothy Noah – Slate. www.slate.com

March 5

I called for Charlie Rangel to step aside pending investigation back in September (http://www.r8ny.com/blog/gatemouth/validating_right_wing_frames.html), so I'm surely under no illusions re the Dems, but there really is a difference between an individual louse and systematic infestationAre 2010 Dems as corrupt as the 2006 GOP? – Joan Walsh – Salon.com

www.salon.com

March 6

I think Conason goes a bit far here–you really don't want the chair of the tax writing panel to be an IRS deadbeat–it undermines the moral authority necessary to ask people to part w/their own money–but his main point is sound

A wave of phony indignation over Charlie Rangel – Joe Conason – Salon.com

www.salon.com

March 6

COMPARED TO WHAT?
Don't like Obama HCR plan? Take a look at the Social Darwinism (the only kind they apprently believe in) being offered by the GOP.

Pass a plan now, even without a public option, or watch Uriah Heep and Ebenezer Scrooge's reforms in action when they take power.

Sink Or Swim | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 6

I was going to write that if Channel 21 ever ran something like "The TAMI Show" outside of pledge week, I might actually send them a check; then I felt guilty, but as I was about to make the call, the announcer said the DVD version included acts not in "the broadcast version," citing the Barbarians. But is there no "broadcaster version," just Channel 21 with a pair of scissors.

March 6

Every time I point out that there are anti-Israel politicans in both parties, my Republican friends say my examples are outliers (unlike, say, Dennis Kucinich). OK, please deny that the ranking Republican on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee is mainstream.

Lugar Suggests Cutting Aid to Israel and PA | NJDC Blog

www.njdc.org

March 8

Great thinking, as usual, from Saletan

The selective crusade against black women's abortions. – By William Saletan – Slate Magazine

www.slate.com

March 8

A little lesson for my friends on the left–you can't get what you want through reconciliation.

A lesson for my friends on the right–health care can be passed, with reconciliation easing the way–and there's nothing radical about doing it. Deal with it.

Jesus Christ, Mike Allen, Reconciliation Is NOT THAT COMPLICATED | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 8

Kucinich just declared he won't give his vote to pass the only health care bill with a snowballs's chance in hell of becoming law. Will somebody give this jerk a primary?–I have my checkbook out.

March 8

In a nutshell, Chait calls out all the jerks, left right AND CENTER

Health Care Reform And Our Myopic Polity | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 8

I sooooo prefer Lawrence O'Donnell to Olbermann (or Madow) that I'm thinking of starting a Facebook group

March 8

Hitchens on the cartoons, redux–Hitch is often cartoonish himself, but here he gets it mostly right.
For those interested, I once dealt with the cartoon and other related issues here:
http://www.r8ny.com/blog/gatemouth/in_my_blog_there_is_a_problem_or_the_church_of_the_poisoned_mind.html
(a bit of nostalgia from the days NYC had a political blog scene which actually mattered)
A nasty attempt to coerce Danish newspapers into apologizing for the cartoons of Muhammad. – By Chri

www.slate.com

March 9

I'm a centrist and the party of centrists is called the Democrats

Republicans are waging a zero sum fight over resources on behalf of the most fortunate members of society and against everybody else.

Paul Ryan And The Republican Vision | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 13

The really scary thing is how so few of these people look that old to me.

Old Jews Telling Jokes

oldjewstellingjokes.com

March 13

By Liz Cheney's criteria, Giuliani, Chertoff and Mukasey may be traitors

Joe Conason: The New McCarthyism – Truthdig

www.truthdig.com

March 13

At last, a Palestinian Leader who seems more interesting in creating opportunities than missing them

Salam Fayyad: The Palestinian with a plan for statehood | Israel | Jewish Journal

www.jewishjournal.com

March 13

It is time we stopped making excuses for this lunatic and terminated his poltical career with extreme prejudice.

FiveThirtyEight: Politics Done Right: Stats Say Kucinich may be Least Valuable Democrat

www.fivethirtyeight.com

March 15 at 6:33am

It is that rare moment in life when one is glad to have lost an Amigo!

March 16

Congrats to Jose Peralta!

Food for thought, except that it soft peddles what a jerk Netanyahu has been. With the existential threat of a nuclear Iran as Israel's highest priority, and with the need for US cooperation in that regard key, you'd think new construction in East Jerusalem would be a relatively low priority. Perhaps he shares with the lunatics in Hamas the desire for a one state solution (aka Israeli suicide)

Myths vs. Reality: The Current State of U.S.-Israel Relations, March 17, 2010 | NJDC

www.njdc.org

March 17

Espada is a gusano, so one has to take this with a grin of salt (unless Felix Ortiz bans it), but I can't help feeling ecstatic

Espada Says Amigos Disbanded With Peralta’s Arrival In Senate

www.cityhallnews.com

March 18

One of America's best writers about Jewish politics contemplates Israel's latest foriegn policy missteps. Money quote: "America can afford stupid politicians. Israel can't."

Israel's Foreign Relations: Incompetence, Stupidity, or Chaos? – International – The Atlantic

www.theatlantic.com

March 18

Gail Collins does for national politics what Gatemouth does for New York; here she gets it right about the vote on HCR, G-d bless her.

Op-Ed Columnist – Saints Preserve Us – NYTimes.com

www.nytimes.com

March 20

Dionne says Republicans can't take "Yes" for an answer.

PostPartisan – Why Democrats are fighting for a Republican health plan

voices.washingtonpost.com

March 21

Mr. Roth's Dr. Spielvogel comments on Health Care Reform: " Now Vee May Perhaps to Begin."

March 21

I've never liked John Dingell–socially conservative, anti-environment, anti-reform, and an Israel basher–but give the man his props; he really cares about bread and butter issues and he really knows how to deliver votes (except to himself)

House passes landmark health bill – Patrick O'Connor – POLITICO.com

www.politico.com

March 22

Vote of Democrats whose district Obama won: 195 Yes-7 No
Votes of Democrats district Obama lost: 17 Yes – 25 No

Want to administer some punishment? Target those 7
Want to throw someone a check? Start with those 17.

FiveThirtyEight: Politics Done Right: Obama's Share Determined Dems' Votes on ObamaCare

www.fivethirtyeight.com

March 22

This is a very heavy favor to be asking. One would think that one making such an ask would have the sense to tell Shas to STFU.

Report: Netanyahu to ask Obama for weapons to strike Iran – Haaretz – Israel News

www.haaretz.com

March 22

Lesson: once you get the left to stop being self-indulgent wankers, they can actually be useful

Democrats Discover Their Base | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 22

Shocking: some Republican electeds encourage their Nuremberg wing. Another (in a different article) called stupak a "baby killer." I'd link that one too, but I'm not sure stupak is worth my effort.

BREAKING: An Ugly Scene | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 22

Big Sleep on TCM; query: other than Barbara Stanwick, has there ever been anyone sexier than Lauren Bacall?

March 22

As the author says; somewhere Harry Truman is smiling (though I suspect he'd grouse just a little)

Truman. Johnson. Obama. | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

A friend wrote to note that somewhere Uncle Teddy was hoisting a pint, but I gotta feeling he’d be doing that regardless.

March 23 at 8:22pm

OK, will all you Republicans stop whining about how Social Security, Medicare and the Civil Rights Act were all bi-partisan and this bill isn't? The bill that just passed is basically a Republican plan. The only reason no Republicans voted for it is because all your moderates have joined our side (in exchange, you got the cud-chewers like Scum Thurmond and Trent Lott)–we are now the moderate Republicans. Cliff Case and Jack Javits would today be in the left wing of our party. Meanwhile, Barry Goldwater, who voted against the Civil Rights Act, would today qualify as one of your moderates and would probably be getting primaried by JD Haworth

Obama's Moderate Health Care Plan | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 23

Can't say I agree with every last word (how do you have a contiguous Palestinian state and a contiguous Israel? Is he going to revive the old Allon plan of an Israeli security flank along the Jordan? Hmm.. maybe not a bad idea), but nonetheless a smart, fair & honest analysis of the situation

Obama and Israel : The New Yorker

www.newyorker.com

March 23

As usual, the prose alternates between brilliant and impenetrable, but no one lays out truths uncomfortable to all sides better than Leon (especially when talking about Israel)–the part about the old Arab man nearly brought tears to my eyes.

Washington Diarist: Mean Streets | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 24

The guy who wrote this has done the Lord's work getting conservatives to come to defense of Justice Department lawyers whose patriotism is under attack by right-wing nutcases, so I think we are obligated to hear him out. And, I think he may even have a point.

Presumed Innocent? | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 24

When I saw these stats, I thought I must have been reading the Onion, but apparently they are real (and scary). Yesterday Thomas Friedman opined that we need a Tea Party of the Center, but we already have a party of the Center, and it's called "the Democrats." Sadly, the party of Eisenhower, Bob Dole, Howard Baker, Ev Dirksen and Gerry Ford has now become the party of delusional psychosis. http://www.r8ny.com/blog/gatemouth/as_centrist_and_substantial_as_the_hole_in_a_bagel.html

Opinion: Scary new GOP poll – Yahoo! News March 25

The dance of reconciliation. OK, what I don't understand is why some Repubs in the House didn’t vote for reconciliation. The rationale was perfect. "The Health Care Reform Law sucks, but this makes it suck a little less." Gets rid of the cornhusker kickback, closes the Part D donut, and cuts Medicaid costs for the states…. Would they really have preferred the bill passed on Sunday without these changes? Schmuck of the day has to be Long Island's Peter King who, by voting against a bill which delays the tax on Cadillac plans has told the unions he usually sucks up to, to suck an egg.

The GOP's last-ditch attempt to railroad health care reform. – By Christopher Beam – Slate Magazine

www.slate.com

March 25

Look, even if the President did propose changing our national anthem to "The Internationale", it would still beat the top two "Tea Party" choices: "Dixie" and "Deutschland Uber Alles"

March 26

Paul Ryan serves of Ayn Rand libertarianism while discarding it few redeeming nuggets of goodness.

Welfare Queens Against Health Care Reform | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 26

Why won't my fellow liberals stand up for this liberal and feminist heroine?

Paul Berman's outraged attack on Ayaan Hirsi Ali's attackers. – By Ron Rosenbaum – Slate Magazine

www.slate.com

March 26

I watched the "debate" on Sunday and was shocked–I expected to hear Republicans score a few points about flaws in the bill, but instead they sounded like a lynch mob. I haven't heard anything as inciteful since the words of Bibi in the weeks before Rabin was assassinated.

Op-Ed Columnist – Going to Extreme – NYTimes.com

www.nytimes.com

March 26

My disdain for the miserable paper this appears in (which I read for local political reasons) is manifested by the fact that I only link their articles on the Sabbath–but for the second week in a row they've improbably run a winner. Newark was where my paternal grandfather settled when he arrived in this country, and where my paternal grandmother and my father were born. Once home of a thriving Jewish community, I now visit it only for the cemeteries and the Iberian cuisine.

City of Graveyards:

www.jewishpress.com

March 26

This would be a great Cialis commercial, though it might require one lasting more than four hours.

Chuck Berry – Reelin and Rockin

vodpod.com

March 27

The title is appropriate, since it got its conservative Republican author, David Frum, fired by the conservative American Enterprise Institute (which, I might add, is their right, but surely speaks volumes)

Sez Hendrik Hertzberg: "The Politburo has dealt appropriately with David Frum, the notorious left devationist antisocial element. Frum has been frog-marched from his Kremlin office and exiled to a minor position in Nobuxograd."

Waterloo | FrumForum

www.frumforum.com

March 28

"an obdurate commitment to a variety of liberalism that emanates from the heart while affecting not to have one"–Nicolas Lemann on Michael Kinsley, but I'm claiming it as my personal brand.

March 28

Hertzberg makes the case against the constitutionality of the filibuster (not sure he's makes the case, but it's so well written you shouldn’t miss it) and calls George Will a weasel (and surely makes the case).

Hendrik Hertzberg: Wrong Way Will : The New Yorker

www.newyorker.com

March 28

A real life version of Operation Shylock, crossed with a bit of Exit Ghost.

Fake Philip Roth, John Grisham interviews : The New Yorker

www.newyorker.com

March 28

Friedman explains the necessity of our policy shift, why it's good for Israelis too, and in passing lays the blame where it belongs "The collapse of the Oslo peace process, combined with the unilateral Israeli pullouts from Lebanon and Gaza — which were followed not by peace but by rocket attacks by Hezbollah and Hamas… on Israel — decimated Israel’s peace camp and the political parties aligned with it."

Op-Ed Columnist – Hobby or Necessity? – NYTimes.com

www.nytimes.com

March 28

Let's give National review credit for editorial integrity and the Weekly Standard credit for being litter box lining

NR Vs. The Weekly Standard, A Case Study | The New Republic

www.tnr.com

March 29

Tip for Vegetarians: Do not eat Streit's Matzohs with red wine.

American Jewish Life Magazine

www.ajlmagazine.com

March 29

Note to my Republican friends (including Mr. Cantor himself): This is the proper way to respond to such atrocious and despicable conduct. Note the absence of any equivocations about understanding people's frustrations.

NJDC Condemns Threat Against Rep. Cantor | NJDC Blog

www.njdc.org

March 30

By contrast, here's the response to an even worse incident from the House Republican's so-called leader: http://dyn.politico.com/members/forums/thread.cfm?catid=1&subcatid=1&threadid=3857356

That rarity of rarities: a great bi-partisan idea:

The right man for the job: Why Mitt Romney should run Obamacare. – By Daniel Gross – Slate Magazine

www.slate.com

March 30

Given the context, it may well be we would ultimately prefer the Doveleh we know, but I can't help but think that this an appropriate time for Pharoh to get his comeuppance

After Lazar Loss, Dov Hikind May Be Next Target Among Brooklyn Jews

www.cityhallnews.com

March 30 at 10:23am

Passover hint: thoroughly rinse charoset off all items before inserting into dishwasher

March 30

Far be it from me to defend a Republican, but Ben Smith, who is Jewish, should know better than to make fun of Carly Fiorina for using the term “breaking bread” to describe a Seder. During the seder, we say the motzi (thanking G-d for giving us bread from the earth) before we eat the matzah. We say of matzah: "this is the poor bread, the bread of affliction." By every religious definition, matzah is bread. And there is surely no bread that breaks more frequently than matzah.

Breaking bread with Fiorina – Ben Smith – POLITICO.com

www.politico.com

March 30

If she had served the chicken soup, but had not given us the gefilte fish; DAYENU! If she had served the gefilte fish, but had not given us the brisket; DAYENU!

March 30

Not only is Obama not a socialist, but he's never been particularly left–here's left academic Adolph Reed on his State Senator back in 1996: "In Chicago, we've gotten a foretaste of the new breed of foundation-hatched black communitarian voices; one of them, a smooth Harvard lawyer with impeccable do-good credentials and vacuous-to-repressive neoliberal politics, has won a state senate seat on a base mainly in the liberal foundation and development worlds. His fundamentally bootstrap line was softened by a patina of the rhetoric of authentic community, talk about meeting in kitchens, small-scale solutions to social problems, and the predictable elevation of process over program — the point where identity politics converges with old-fashioned middle-class reform in favoring form over substance. I suspect that his ilk is the wave of the future in U.S. black politics" Arcticle also has similar criticism from BILL AYRES

Obama and the left, '95 edition – Ben Smith – POLITICO.com

March 30

Gatemouth's credo:

People tend to hate me
'Cause I never smile
As I ransack their homes
…They want to shake my hand

Focusing on nowhere
Investigating miles
I'm a seeker
I'm a really desperate man…

…I learned how to raise my voice in anger
Yeah, but look at my face, ain't this a smile?
I'm happy when life's good
And when it's bad I cry
I've got values but I don't know how or why

The Who – The Seeker

March 31

Gatemouth's credo part two:

Well in between the pages of the glossy magazines
There's a coffee table world I could never ever fit in
l shout about how I could never buy it
But I stand up and fight For the right to go and try it

l'm a born fighter

ROCKPILE – Nick Lowe, Dave Edmunds – "Born Fighter" – 1979 video

March 31

Uncategorized