The UFT has raised some good points on this issue, but the overall reality is hypocrisy. If principals make qualitative determinations, they say, the result is favoritism. So it appears Bloomberg/Klein took the bait and went with an "objective" measure — the change in test scores. Not fair says the UFT — the tests are flawed. There is no means of evaluation the UFT would accept, other a huge increase in the number of administrators sitting in classes — and rotating to get a diversity of views. Of course, any increase in administrative costs cheats the children, they would say. Well, it appears that a huge increase in administrative costs is what Governor Cuomo wants.
"Gov. Andrew Cuomo on Friday proposed tougher criteria to evaluate teachers including greater use of student test scores, more rigorous observation in the classroom." So who would be doing that observation in situation where more and more money is going to the retired? And doesn't this mean that because NYC cannot afford such an observation, it has no right to evaluate teachers.