What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 3

|

I exited college during the severe recession of the early 1980s, making graduate school seem attractive, and then exited graduate school during the housing bubble of the late 1980s.  Having had a housing markets class in graduate school, realizing the bubble (like this one) would burst, but unsure how long it would take, my wife and I had a plan.  We would live as cheaply as possible, save our money, and then move to a metro area in reasonably-priced Upstate New York, where we had attended college and actually liked the cool summers, lovely falls, and snowy winters (we won’t talk about March, April, and May).  For a variety of reasons – our increasing ties to the city and the end of the bubble here included – it never happened.  But one factor was we found that none of the Upstate metro areas had a large and diverse enough labor market to allow us to have careers.  Perhaps we could get a job, but it might be the job, and it would be very difficult to get another one without moving.  In other words we didn’t move to Upstate New York, in part, because none of the Upstate Metro areas, by itself, is a significant place anymore.  That is a problem Upstate will have to overcome.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 2

|

How does this sound for an economic development slogan:  “Upstate New York, we’re just like everyplace else, except we’re older, we’re colder, we have lots of toxic contamination left over from the industrial era, we have high taxes not for services but to pay for the debts and pensions of the past, and we are highly unionized and expect higher pay and more restrictive work rules than other parts of the country.”  Well, that’s the truth isn’t it?  It isn’t the whole truth, not by a long shot.  But if Upstate New York continues position itself in the economy based on being “just like everyplace else,” it is the only truth that matters.

What I Would Do About Upstate: Part 2

|

How does this sound for an economic development slogan:  “Upstate New York, we’re just like everyplace else, except we’re older, we’re colder, we have lots of toxic contamination left over from the industrial era, we have high taxes not for services but to pay for the debts and pensions of the past, and we are highly unionized and expect higher pay and more restrictive work rules than other parts of the country.”  Well, that’s the truth isn’t it?  It isn’t the whole truth, not by a long shot.  But if Upstate New York continues position itself in the economy based on being “just like everyplace else,” it is the only truth that matters.