The U.S. Census Bureau released 2005 economic data from its American Community Survey data yesterday, and having looked at those numbers and having analyzed similar numbers professionally for 20 years, the first-day stories in the newspapers surprised me. As far as I am concerned, everyone got it wrong – so wrong that they must have written the stories before they came out and plopped in the numbers when they arrived.
The story as reported is that poverty is unchanged, and this shows that New York City is not a good place for the poor. The view appears to have been pushed by poverty advocates, who are advocating for more money to be sent their way. The reality is that poverty has declined significantly, but this isn’t necessarily good news for the poor either, because the advocates and analysts fundamentally misunderstand the factors that influence the poverty rate at the local level. At the national level, the poverty rate is determined by changes in the economy, in society, and in public policy. The national poverty rate was significantly higher in 2005 than in 2000, though slightly lower than in 2004. At the local level, on the other hand, the poverty rate it is a function of who moves in (or is kept out), who moves out (or is pushed out), who is born and who dies off. Local changes in the poverty rate may have nothing to do with whether individuals are getting richer or poorer whatsoever.
