Before Voting on the School Budget, Download This

|

The U.S. Census Bureau has released its education finance data for the 2005-2006 school year, with information available on revenues by source and expenditures by type for every school district in the United States. I’ve summed this information to create totals for the United States, New Jersey, New York State, the Downstate Suburbs, Upstate New York, and New York City, divided the totals by the number of students to get per student figures, adjusted the per student figures for the cost of living for the higher cost Downstate and New Jersey areas, and adjusted 2002 data for inflation for a comparison with 2006. The data is in two attached spreadsheet, one a summary by broad areas with a comparison with FY 2002, and the other with data for every school district in New York State in 2006. I suggest that New York State residents outside New York City download these spreadsheets, look them over, and think about them before voting on their school budgets.

When I first started compiling public finance data many years ago, what stood out was how low New York City’s elementary and secondary school spending was, as a share of the income of its residents, despite very high local taxes. As will be described briefly below and in more detail in the next post, however, New York City was already spending plenty of money in FY 2006 based on the national average, even before the “historic” (in ex-Governor Spitzer’s words) increases in state school aid over the past two years. High by national standards, the city’s spending remains far lower than in other parts of the state. That, however, is not because the city’s school spending is low, but because spending elsewhere in New York State — already high a decade ago — is now unreasonably high. So high, in fact, that one wonders what share of the money is actually going to education. Unreasonably high spending elsewhere in the state, rather than low spending in New York City, is now the biggest education finance problem for New York.

NYC School Finance At the Peak

|

A quick look at the website of the Fiscal Policy Unit of the New York State Department of Education shows the school finance data for the 2005 to 2006 school year has been released. That year, and the following year, was probably as good as it is going to get for the New York City public schools. The New York State Court of Appeals subsequently ruled that although it was wrong for the state legislature to make financial arrangements that eliminated the possibility of many NYC children receiving a decent education, there would be no consequences for those who benefited from those arrangements in the past, and no judicial restrictions on doing so again in the future. The pattern of New York City’s state education funding being cut, while that for the rest of the state is increased, in recessions is therefore likely to recur. Also recurring are pension enhancements for those cashing and moving out, paid for by reduced pay for future teachers and reduced services for NYC children, with a recent massively-costly example just enacted. With doom once again approaching, let’s look at the “good old days” for the public schools.

The Generational War Continues: The UFT Allows Bloomberg to Score Political Points as they Jointly Destroy the Future

|

Mayor Bloomberg and the UFT have agreed to allow teachers to retire with full pension and health benefits at age 55, pending approval by the state legislature (which has already passed the deal unanimously before, with Pataki’s veto). You find out about that, and not in detail, at the end of articles today in the Times, Post and Sun. The part of the deal that led those articles, and led the city’s press release that was used to quickly and easily create those articles, is that there will be “merit pay,” something that may allow Bloomberg to make a political point. The teachers would receive bonuses if they worked in low-performing schools and those schools improved. But that may be a pilot program, which can be terminated after Bloomberg leaves, and is funded only with private donations, whose future is at best uncertain. The real order of significance can be found in on the UFT website and in the Daily News story, where this part of the agreement is given its proper insignificance. Or more significance than it deserves.

The Generational War Continues: The UFT Allows Bloomberg to Score Political Points as they Jointly Destroy the Future

|

Mayor Bloomberg and the UFT have agreed to allow teachers to retire with full pension and health benefits at age 55, pending approval by the state legislature (which has already passed the deal unanimously before, with Pataki’s veto). You find out about that, and not in detail, at the end of articles today in the Times, Post and Sun. The part of the deal that led those articles, and led the city’s press release that was used to quickly and easily create those articles, is that there will be “merit pay,” something that may allow Bloomberg to make a political point. The teachers would receive bonuses if they worked in low-performing schools and those schools improved. But that may be a pilot program, which can be terminated after Bloomberg leaves, and is funded only with private donations, whose future is at best uncertain. The real order of significance can be found in on the UFT website and in the Daily News story, where this part of the agreement is given its proper insignificance. Or more significance than it deserves.

The Generational War Continues: The UFT Allows Bloomberg to Score Political Points as they Jointly Destroy the Future

|

Mayor Bloomberg and the UFT have agreed to allow teachers to retire with full pension and health benefits at age 55, pending approval by the state legislature (which has already passed the deal unanimously before, with Pataki’s veto). You find out about that, and not in detail, at the end of articles today in the Times, Post and Sun. The part of the deal that led those articles, and led the city’s press release that was used to quickly and easily create those articles, is that there will be “merit pay,” something that may allow Bloomberg to make a political point. The teachers would receive bonuses if they worked in low-performing schools and those schools improved. But that may be a pilot program, which can be terminated after Bloomberg leaves, and is funded only with private donations, whose future is at best uncertain. The real order of significance can be found in on the UFT website and in the Daily News story, where this part of the agreement is given its proper insignificance. Or more significance than it deserves.

The Generational War Continues: The UFT Allows Bloomberg to Score Political Points as they Jointly Destroy the Future

|

Mayor Bloomberg and the UFT have agreed to allow teachers to retire with full pension and health benefits at age 55, pending approval by the state legislature (which has already passed the deal unanimously before, with Pataki’s veto). You find out about that, and not in detail, at the end of articles today in the Times, Post and Sun. The part of the deal that led those articles, and led the city’s press release that was used to quickly and easily create those articles, is that there will be “merit pay,” something that may allow Bloomberg to make a political point. The teachers would receive bonuses if they worked in low-performing schools and those schools improved. But that may be a pilot program, which can be terminated after Bloomberg leaves, and is funded only with private donations, whose future is at best uncertain. The real order of significance can be found in on the UFT website and in the Daily News story, where this part of the agreement is given its proper insignificance. Or more significance than it deserves.

The Generational War Continues: The UFT Allows Bloomberg to Score Political Points as they Jointly Destroy the Future

|

Mayor Bloomberg and the UFT have agreed to allow teachers to retire with full pension and health benefits at age 55, pending approval by the state legislature (which has already passed the deal unanimously before, with Pataki’s veto). You find out about that, and not in detail, at the end of articles today in the Times, Post and Sun. The part of the deal that led those articles, and led the city’s press release that was used to quickly and easily create those articles, is that there will be “merit pay,” something that may allow Bloomberg to make a political point. The teachers would receive bonuses if they worked in low-performing schools and those schools improved. But that may be a pilot program, which can be terminated after Bloomberg leaves, and is funded only with private donations, whose future is at best uncertain. The real order of significance can be found in on the UFT website and in the Daily News story, where this part of the agreement is given its proper insignificance. Or more significance than it deserves.

The Generational War Continues: The UFT Allows Bloomberg to Score Political Points as they Jointly Destroy the Future

|

Mayor Bloomberg and the UFT have agreed to allow teachers to retire with full pension and health benefits at age 55, pending approval by the state legislature (which has already passed the deal unanimously before, with Pataki’s veto). You find out about that, and not in detail, at the end of articles today in the Times, Post and Sun. The part of the deal that led those articles, and led the city’s press release that was used to quickly and easily create those articles, is that there will be “merit pay,” something that may allow Bloomberg to make a political point. The teachers would receive bonuses if they worked in low-performing schools and those schools improved. But that may be a pilot program, which can be terminated after Bloomberg leaves, and is funded only with private donations, whose future is at best uncertain. The real order of significance can be found in on the UFT website and in the Daily News story, where this part of the agreement is given its proper insignificance. Or more significance than it deserves.

Move Forward on Schools Not Backward

|

Mayoral control of the New York City public schools doesn’t expire until June 2009, but with the state legislature seemingly in the mood to oppose anything Mayor Bloomberg is in favor of, the Mayor has already started a public relations push. I happened to be at home one day last week and saw a commercial on the subject, albeit obliquely on the subject, on daytime television. And in late June Crain’s NY Business reported that in a breakfast for business leaders the Mayor “vowed to fight for renewal of mayoral control of the school system when the law authorizing it expires.” “It's hard for the Legislature not to reauthorize something where parents say, ‘My kids for the first time in memory are getting the kind of education they need to compete in the world,’” the Mayor is quoted as saying. Another publication quoted the Mayor as not wanting to go backward on education. Well, it isn’t hard for the New York State legislature to do anything, regardless of how good or bad it is for the city’s children. They don’t care. They don’t have to. But even if they did, it isn’t clear Mayoral control should simply be extended as it.

Move Forward on Schools Not Backward

|

Mayoral control of the New York City public schools doesn’t expire until June 2009, but with the state legislature seemingly in the mood to oppose anything Mayor Bloomberg is in favor of, the Mayor has already started a public relations push. I happened to be at home one day last week and saw a commercial on the subject, albeit obliquely on the subject, on daytime television. And in late June Crain’s NY Business reported that in a breakfast for business leaders the Mayor “vowed to fight for renewal of mayoral control of the school system when the law authorizing it expires.” “It's hard for the Legislature not to reauthorize something where parents say, ‘My kids for the first time in memory are getting the kind of education they need to compete in the world,’” the Mayor is quoted as saying. Another publication quoted the Mayor as not wanting to go backward on education. Well, it isn’t hard for the New York State legislature to do anything, regardless of how good or bad it is for the city’s children. They don’t care. They don’t have to. But even if they did, it isn’t clear Mayoral control should simply be extended as it.