Giving Poor Countries a Fish and then Taking It Away

|

According to a Chinese proverb, “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach him how to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” It turns out that for decades U.S. food aid policies have been based on giving poor countries that fish, or rather giving them food produced in the United States and shipped abroad, because the program has been as much a subsidy for grain producers and shipping companies as an act of charity. A few years ago the Bush Administration, which I agree with about 15% of the time, proposed using some of America’s food aid money to buy food in the countries where the aid was distributed. If American food was the cheapest, then the private sector would get it there, but otherwise American food aid would support, rather than displace, a network of local farmers and food businesses, providing them with the income to recover and develop. It was and is a good idea.

This policy, however, was blocked in Congress for years by an “iron triangle” of U.S. agribusiness interests, shipping interests, and the food aid non-profits that distribute the assistance. And now, in a stunning reversal the The Economist magazine recently called “the end of cheap food,” events have overtaken that debate, putting countries with weakened food production and distribution networks at risk of severe and unmitigated famine for the first time in 30 years.

Giving Poor Countries a Fish and then Taking It Away

|

According to a Chinese proverb, “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach him how to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” It turns out that for decades U.S. food aid policies have been based on giving poor countries that fish, or rather giving them food produced in the United States and shipped abroad, because the program has been as much a subsidy for grain producers and shipping companies as an act of charity. A few years ago the Bush Administration, which I agree with about 15% of the time, proposed using some of America’s food aid money to buy food in the countries where the aid was distributed. If American food was the cheapest, then the private sector would get it there, but otherwise American food aid would support, rather than displace, a network of local farmers and food businesses, providing them with the income to recover and develop. It was and is a good idea.

This policy, however, was blocked in Congress for years by an “iron triangle” of U.S. agribusiness interests, shipping interests, and the food aid non-profits that distribute the assistance. And now, in a stunning reversal the The Economist magazine recently called “the end of cheap food,” events have overtaken that debate, putting countries with weakened food production and distribution networks at risk of severe and unmitigated famine for the first time in 30 years.

Giving Poor Countries a Fish and then Taking It Away

|

According to a Chinese proverb, “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach him how to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” It turns out that for decades U.S. food aid policies have been based on giving poor countries that fish, or rather giving them food produced in the United States and shipped abroad, because the program has been as much a subsidy for grain producers and shipping companies as an act of charity. A few years ago the Bush Administration, which I agree with about 15% of the time, proposed using some of America’s food aid money to buy food in the countries where the aid was distributed. If American food was the cheapest, then the private sector would get it there, but otherwise American food aid would support, rather than displace, a network of local farmers and food businesses, providing them with the income to recover and develop. It was and is a good idea.

This policy, however, was blocked in Congress for years by an “iron triangle” of U.S. agribusiness interests, shipping interests, and the food aid non-profits that distribute the assistance. And now, in a stunning reversal the The Economist magazine recently called “the end of cheap food,” events have overtaken that debate, putting countries with weakened food production and distribution networks at risk of severe and unmitigated famine for the first time in 30 years.

Permalancer’s Revolt (It’s About Time)

|

A prior generation of workers preserved rich pensions for itself, while limiting my generation and those after to 401Ks, with the company at first contributing to them, and then stopping. And, I have written elsewhere, younger generations will not get health insurance either. The IRS, in order for health insurance to be excluded from taxable income, requires all company employees to receive it. But employers and employees with seniority have gotten around that by hiring the young as “freelancers” and “contractors,” a category that includes a growing share of the workforce. Now, reported the New York Times, “scores of workers from MTV Networks walked off the job yesterday afternoon, filling the sidewalk outside the headquarters of its corporate parent, Viacom, to protest recent changes in benefits. The walkout highlighted the concerns of a category of workers who are sometimes called permalancers: permanent freelancers who work like full-time employees but do not receive the same benefits.” Hey kids, you might want to turn your attention to public policy. Viacom is a loving parent compared with the federal, state and local governments.

Freelancers are paying two local income taxes (including the Unincorporated Business Tax) while the retired are exempted from both state and local income taxes in New York. The young and workign poor are not receiving health insurance, but their taxes pay for those who receive it from the public sector (seniors, public employees) and offset the taxes lost to the health insurance tax exemption.  And that is just two examples of the growing generational inequities.  Worse for today’s young than for me, undoubtedly worse for my kids than for today’s young, if something isn’t done.  Compared with many of the self employed, these college-educated media workers are in fact well off. 

Permalancer’s Revolt (It’s About Time)

|

A prior generation of workers preserved rich pensions for itself, while limiting my generation and those after to 401Ks, with the company at first contributing to them, and then stopping. And, I have written elsewhere, younger generations will not get health insurance either. The IRS, in order for health insurance to be excluded from taxable income, requires all company employees to receive it. But employers and employees with seniority have gotten around that by hiring the young as “freelancers” and “contractors,” a category that includes a growing share of the workforce. Now, reported the New York Times, “scores of workers from MTV Networks walked off the job yesterday afternoon, filling the sidewalk outside the headquarters of its corporate parent, Viacom, to protest recent changes in benefits. The walkout highlighted the concerns of a category of workers who are sometimes called permalancers: permanent freelancers who work like full-time employees but do not receive the same benefits.” Hey kids, you might want to turn your attention to public policy. Viacom is a loving parent compared with the federal, state and local governments.

Freelancers are paying two local income taxes (including the Unincorporated Business Tax) while the retired are exempted from both state and local income taxes in New York. The young and workign poor are not receiving health insurance, but their taxes pay for those who receive it from the public sector (seniors, public employees) and offset the taxes lost to the health insurance tax exemption.  And that is just two examples of the growing generational inequities.  Worse for today’s young than for me, undoubtedly worse for my kids than for today’s young, if something isn’t done.  Compared with many of the self employed, these college-educated media workers are in fact well off. 

Permalancer’s Revolt (It’s About Time)

|

A prior generation of workers preserved rich pensions for itself, while limiting my generation and those after to 401Ks, with the company at first contributing to them, and then stopping. And, I have written elsewhere, younger generations will not get health insurance either. The IRS, in order for health insurance to be excluded from taxable income, requires all company employees to receive it. But employers and employees with seniority have gotten around that by hiring the young as “freelancers” and “contractors,” a category that includes a growing share of the workforce. Now, reported the New York Times, “scores of workers from MTV Networks walked off the job yesterday afternoon, filling the sidewalk outside the headquarters of its corporate parent, Viacom, to protest recent changes in benefits. The walkout highlighted the concerns of a category of workers who are sometimes called permalancers: permanent freelancers who work like full-time employees but do not receive the same benefits.” Hey kids, you might want to turn your attention to public policy. Viacom is a loving parent compared with the federal, state and local governments.

Freelancers are paying two local income taxes (including the Unincorporated Business Tax) while the retired are exempted from both state and local income taxes in New York. The young and workign poor are not receiving health insurance, but their taxes pay for those who receive it from the public sector (seniors, public employees) and offset the taxes lost to the health insurance tax exemption.  And that is just two examples of the growing generational inequities.  Worse for today’s young than for me, undoubtedly worse for my kids than for today’s young, if something isn’t done.  Compared with many of the self employed, these college-educated media workers are in fact well off. 

Permalancer’s Revolt (It’s About Time)

|

A prior generation of workers preserved rich pensions for itself, while limiting my generation and those after to 401Ks, with the company at first contributing to them, and then stopping. And, I have written elsewhere, younger generations will not get health insurance either. The IRS, in order for health insurance to be excluded from taxable income, requires all company employees to receive it. But employers and employees with seniority have gotten around that by hiring the young as “freelancers” and “contractors,” a category that includes a growing share of the workforce. Now, reported the New York Times, “scores of workers from MTV Networks walked off the job yesterday afternoon, filling the sidewalk outside the headquarters of its corporate parent, Viacom, to protest recent changes in benefits. The walkout highlighted the concerns of a category of workers who are sometimes called permalancers: permanent freelancers who work like full-time employees but do not receive the same benefits.” Hey kids, you might want to turn your attention to public policy. Viacom is a loving parent compared with the federal, state and local governments.

Freelancers are paying two local income taxes (including the Unincorporated Business Tax) while the retired are exempted from both state and local income taxes in New York. The young and workign poor are not receiving health insurance, but their taxes pay for those who receive it from the public sector (seniors, public employees) and offset the taxes lost to the health insurance tax exemption.  And that is just two examples of the growing generational inequities.  Worse for today’s young than for me, undoubtedly worse for my kids than for today’s young, if something isn’t done.  Compared with many of the self employed, these college-educated media workers are in fact well off. 

Permalancer’s Revolt (It’s About Time)

|

A prior generation of workers preserved rich pensions for itself, while limiting my generation and those after to 401Ks, with the company at first contributing to them, and then stopping. And, I have written elsewhere, younger generations will not get health insurance either. The IRS, in order for health insurance to be excluded from taxable income, requires all company employees to receive it. But employers and employees with seniority have gotten around that by hiring the young as “freelancers” and “contractors,” a category that includes a growing share of the workforce. Now, reported the New York Times, “scores of workers from MTV Networks walked off the job yesterday afternoon, filling the sidewalk outside the headquarters of its corporate parent, Viacom, to protest recent changes in benefits. The walkout highlighted the concerns of a category of workers who are sometimes called permalancers: permanent freelancers who work like full-time employees but do not receive the same benefits.” Hey kids, you might want to turn your attention to public policy. Viacom is a loving parent compared with the federal, state and local governments.

Freelancers are paying two local income taxes (including the Unincorporated Business Tax) while the retired are exempted from both state and local income taxes in New York. The young and workign poor are not receiving health insurance, but their taxes pay for those who receive it from the public sector (seniors, public employees) and offset the taxes lost to the health insurance tax exemption.  And that is just two examples of the growing generational inequities.  Worse for today’s young than for me, undoubtedly worse for my kids than for today’s young, if something isn’t done.  Compared with many of the self employed, these college-educated media workers are in fact well off. 

BARACK OBAMA, OPRAH WINFREY AND THE TEN ZILLION POUND GORILLA. (Part One of Three)

|

I don’t profess to know the man or woman who invented the phrase: “the large elephant sitting at the back of the room”; even though I believe that whoever did it is a member of my generation. You see, I never saw the term used in any of the many old English Literature books I have studied. I do think that the inventor of this term deserves the Nobel Prize for English; the term is that good. It refers to the tacit presence of something or someone that causes pain, displeasure, angst, discomfort and/or such, to some, most, or all of those present (wherever). So; taking my cue from the inventor (s), I am now suggesting a spin-off term: the ten zillion ton gorilla sitting at the back of the room. In this case: I am referring to “race”.

If I Was Tim Russert

|

I might be a minority of one here but I don’t believe that Tim Russert “grilled” Rudy on Meet the Press. I think that Russert missed giving Rudy the tough follow-up questions that could have really put Rudy on the spot.

For example, Russert asked Rudy a few tough questions about one of foreign policy advisors Norman Podhoretz including this exchange –

MR. RUSSERT: Podhoretz also wrote this, this week. “I entertain an even darker suspicion. It is that the intelligence community, which has for some years now been leaking material calculated to undermine George W. Bush, is doing it again. This time the purpose is to head off the possibility that the president may order air strikes on the Iranian nuclear installations.” Do you think the intelligence community is intentionally putting this information out?