Engaging the State Budget: More Tax Breaks for Some in Every Boom, Higher Tax Rates for All In Every Bust

|

Every time a bull stock market puffs up the pension funds, the State of New York passes more sweeteners for those cashing in and moving out, but every time a bear market causes pension cost to soar, state-appointed arbitrators and control boards cut pay and benefits for hires while leaving those with seniority untouched. Because the sweeteners and the lower pay for new hires occur at different times, no one says the policy is to enrich one generation of workers at the expense of another. But that is what the policy is. Whenever the economy is flush, money is borrowed to allow more of it to flow to politically powerful priorities on which New York City and State spending is already above average. And when “uncontrollable” spending such as interest on debts subsequently soars, other public services such as parks, libraries, and the Administration of Children’s services are first in line for the axe. Because the spending increases and cuts occur at different times, no one says New York City and New York State policy is to spend more where we already spend more and less where we already spend less. But it is. Similarly, every time a hot economy swells New York City and New York State tax revenues, our elected officials curry favor with politically active discrete groups by handing out tax breaks.

And when the economy cools and tax revenues drop, tax rates are increased, nailing those who didn’t benefit from the breaks, or benefited less than others. Again, because the tax breaks and rate increases occur a few years apart, no one says New York’s policy is to impose higher and higher tax rates on a narrower and narrower tax base. But it is.

Engaging the State Budget: More Tax Breaks for Some in Every Boom, Higher Tax Rates for All In Every Bust

|

Every time a bull stock market puffs up the pension funds, the State of New York passes more sweeteners for those cashing in and moving out, but every time a bear market causes pension cost to soar, state-appointed arbitrators and control boards cut pay and benefits for hires while leaving those with seniority untouched. Because the sweeteners and the lower pay for new hires occur at different times, no one says the policy is to enrich one generation of workers at the expense of another. But that is what the policy is. Whenever the economy is flush, money is borrowed to allow more of it to flow to politically powerful priorities on which New York City and State spending is already above average. And when “uncontrollable” spending such as interest on debts subsequently soars, other public services such as parks, libraries, and the Administration of Children’s services are first in line for the axe. Because the spending increases and cuts occur at different times, no one says New York City and New York State policy is to spend more where we already spend more and less where we already spend less. But it is. Similarly, every time a hot economy swells New York City and New York State tax revenues, our elected officials curry favor with politically active discrete groups by handing out tax breaks.

And when the economy cools and tax revenues drop, tax rates are increased, nailing those who didn’t benefit from the breaks, or benefited less than others. Again, because the tax breaks and rate increases occur a few years apart, no one says New York’s policy is to impose higher and higher tax rates on a narrower and narrower tax base. But it is.

Mayor Bloomberg Is Correct On This One

|

Say what you want about our mayor and his modus operandi but he has gotten a few things right over his tenure. I am not a big fan of his but I don’t dislike him either. He was absolutely correct with his ban on cigarettes in certain public establishments; taking the flack in order to get that policy into law. He was correct in putting public education on the front burner; even though I feel that his successes in this area were somewhat exaggerated: but you can’t deny that he has genuinely tried to deal with the issue. I think that in principle he was correct to suggest some type of congestion pricing formula for Manhattan’s traffic congestion problem; hopefully the details would be worked out before pigs grow wings. His positions on the issues surrounding illegal firearms (guns, gun shows, gun sales, etc.) are sensible and timely; and there are other things I could commend him on. Of course there are also many others that I could critique him on; like his police department that’s totally out of control, and the fact that big developers have surely enjoyed his tenure in profitable ways; but that’s not the issue here. You can always view my column in the archives (where I called him a leprechaun), to get a better sense of how I felt about him just a year ago.

Engaging the State Budget: What Has Posterity Ever Done for Me?

|

There is no more hypocritical whine than older New York State residents complaining that their children find it necessary to move away to find a decent life for themselves. It is hypocritical because while providing the nation’s richest Medicaid services for senior citizens, and excluding retirement income from state (and in New York City local) income taxes, New York has made decision after decision for nearly 20 years to favor those cashing in and moving out at the expense of the state’s future, which is now the present. In general, Republicans sell out the future with debts, caused by tax breaks and rich government contracts for business. Democrats do it with pension enhancements for those with seniority and already retired, passed every time a stock market boom swells pension fund coffers, followed by lower wages and benefits for new hires, agreed to by the Democrats’ union allies every time high pension costs leave the government broke. Now that the bills are starting to come due, there is a bit of unease in Albany, as our “leaders” look around for someone to blame. But with every deal passing the state legislature 212 to 0 they are all to blame. So are the older generations that have gratefully accepted this largesse without questioning who would pay how much. It is those deals that should be undone, and those generations who should pay first, if a recession and fiscal crisis requires sacrifice. To do otherwise would mean that Spitzer and Francis are merely continuing the practices of the now-despised Pataki to pump up the current Governor’s short-term popularity. In the end, Spitzer would be despised as well.

Engaging the State Budget: What Has Posterity Ever Done for Me?

|

There is no more hypocritical whine than older New York State residents complaining that their children find it necessary to move away to find a decent life for themselves. It is hypocritical because while providing the nation’s richest Medicaid services for senior citizens, and excluding retirement income from state (and in New York City local) income taxes, New York has made decision after decision for nearly 20 years to favor those cashing in and moving out at the expense of the state’s future, which is now the present. In general, Republicans sell out the future with debts, caused by tax breaks and rich government contracts for business. Democrats do it with pension enhancements for those with seniority and already retired, passed every time a stock market boom swells pension fund coffers, followed by lower wages and benefits for new hires, agreed to by the Democrats’ union allies every time high pension costs leave the government broke. Now that the bills are starting to come due, there is a bit of unease in Albany, as our “leaders” look around for someone to blame. But with every deal passing the state legislature 212 to 0 they are all to blame. So are the older generations that have gratefully accepted this largesse without questioning who would pay how much. It is those deals that should be undone, and those generations who should pay first, if a recession and fiscal crisis requires sacrifice. To do otherwise would mean that Spitzer and Francis are merely continuing the practices of the now-despised Pataki to pump up the current Governor’s short-term popularity. In the end, Spitzer would be despised as well.

Engaging the State Budget: What Has Posterity Ever Done for Me?

|

There is no more hypocritical whine than older New York State residents complaining that their children find it necessary to move away to find a decent life for themselves. It is hypocritical because while providing the nation’s richest Medicaid services for senior citizens, and excluding retirement income from state (and in New York City local) income taxes, New York has made decision after decision for nearly 20 years to favor those cashing in and moving out at the expense of the state’s future, which is now the present. In general, Republicans sell out the future with debts, caused by tax breaks and rich government contracts for business. Democrats do it with pension enhancements for those with seniority and already retired, passed every time a stock market boom swells pension fund coffers, followed by lower wages and benefits for new hires, agreed to by the Democrats’ union allies every time high pension costs leave the government broke. Now that the bills are starting to come due, there is a bit of unease in Albany, as our “leaders” look around for someone to blame. But with every deal passing the state legislature 212 to 0 they are all to blame. So are the older generations that have gratefully accepted this largesse without questioning who would pay how much. It is those deals that should be undone, and those generations who should pay first, if a recession and fiscal crisis requires sacrifice. To do otherwise would mean that Spitzer and Francis are merely continuing the practices of the now-despised Pataki to pump up the current Governor’s short-term popularity. In the end, Spitzer would be despised as well.

Engaging the State Budget: What Has Posterity Ever Done for Me?

|

There is no more hypocritical whine than older New York State residents complaining that their children find it necessary to move away to find a decent life for themselves. It is hypocritical because while providing the nation’s richest Medicaid services for senior citizens, and excluding retirement income from state (and in New York City local) income taxes, New York has made decision after decision for nearly 20 years to favor those cashing in and moving out at the expense of the state’s future, which is now the present. In general, Republicans sell out the future with debts, caused by tax breaks and rich government contracts for business. Democrats do it with pension enhancements for those with seniority and already retired, passed every time a stock market boom swells pension fund coffers, followed by lower wages and benefits for new hires, agreed to by the Democrats’ union allies every time high pension costs leave the government broke. Now that the bills are starting to come due, there is a bit of unease in Albany, as our “leaders” look around for someone to blame. But with every deal passing the state legislature 212 to 0 they are all to blame. So are the older generations that have gratefully accepted this largesse without questioning who would pay how much. It is those deals that should be undone, and those generations who should pay first, if a recession and fiscal crisis requires sacrifice. To do otherwise would mean that Spitzer and Francis are merely continuing the practices of the now-despised Pataki to pump up the current Governor’s short-term popularity. In the end, Spitzer would be despised as well.

Engaging the State Budget: What Has Posterity Ever Done for Me?

|

There is no more hypocritical whine than older New York State residents complaining that their children find it necessary to move away to find a decent life for themselves. It is hypocritical because while providing the nation’s richest Medicaid services for senior citizens, and excluding retirement income from state (and in New York City local) income taxes, New York has made decision after decision for nearly 20 years to favor those cashing in and moving out at the expense of the state’s future, which is now the present. In general, Republicans sell out the future with debts, caused by tax breaks and rich government contracts for business. Democrats do it with pension enhancements for those with seniority and already retired, passed every time a stock market boom swells pension fund coffers, followed by lower wages and benefits for new hires, agreed to by the Democrats’ union allies every time high pension costs leave the government broke. Now that the bills are starting to come due, there is a bit of unease in Albany, as our “leaders” look around for someone to blame. But with every deal passing the state legislature 212 to 0 they are all to blame. So are the older generations that have gratefully accepted this largesse without questioning who would pay how much. It is those deals that should be undone, and those generations who should pay first, if a recession and fiscal crisis requires sacrifice. To do otherwise would mean that Spitzer and Francis are merely continuing the practices of the now-despised Pataki to pump up the current Governor’s short-term popularity. In the end, Spitzer would be despised as well.

Engaging the State Budget: What Has Posterity Ever Done for Me?

|

There is no more hypocritical whine than older New York State residents complaining that their children find it necessary to move away to find a decent life for themselves. It is hypocritical because while providing the nation’s richest Medicaid services for senior citizens, and excluding retirement income from state (and in New York City local) income taxes, New York has made decision after decision for nearly 20 years to favor those cashing in and moving out at the expense of the state’s future, which is now the present. In general, Republicans sell out the future with debts, caused by tax breaks and rich government contracts for business. Democrats do it with pension enhancements for those with seniority and already retired, passed every time a stock market boom swells pension fund coffers, followed by lower wages and benefits for new hires, agreed to by the Democrats’ union allies every time high pension costs leave the government broke. Now that the bills are starting to come due, there is a bit of unease in Albany, as our “leaders” look around for someone to blame. But with every deal passing the state legislature 212 to 0 they are all to blame. So are the older generations that have gratefully accepted this largesse without questioning who would pay how much. It is those deals that should be undone, and those generations who should pay first, if a recession and fiscal crisis requires sacrifice. To do otherwise would mean that Spitzer and Francis are merely continuing the practices of the now-despised Pataki to pump up the current Governor’s short-term popularity. In the end, Spitzer would be despised as well.

Question For Eliot Spitzer and Paul Francis: Are Your Planning on Hitting Up the Same Victims Again?

|

Newsday has reported that Governor Eliot Spitzer and budget director Paul Francis are “engaging the public as we determine our priorities for how to best use the state's limited financial resources, while minimizing the burden on taxpayers and keeping our business climate competitive.” If by “the public” they mean those with the greatest sense of entitlement and the most hooks into the state legislature, then all they have to do is choose the same victims to pay more or get less as in the early to mid-1990s and early 2000s. That is the “humble” thing to do, since it is the path of least resistance in the state legislature, and the path least likely to generate reputation-tainting opposition advertisements. If that is the path they choose, however, the Spitzer Administration will have failed the people of this state to an unimaginable extent. My suggestion, if they wish to “engage” with it, is to do the opposite. Reduce spending in categories and places where it is high, not where it is low. Raise revenues by eliminating tax breaks, even popular ones, rather than raising rates. And stop destroying the common future in order to curry favor with those with the greatest sense of entitlement in the present. For health care and aid to local governments, the details are below. And they assume a much more difficult fiscal environment than has been admitted thus far.