Is New York City Still the City That Doesn’t Work?

|

From the late 1960s to the early 1990s, New York City could be characterized as the “city that doesn’t work.” Reversing a historic pattern that had prevailed until that time, the share of NYC adults employed, or even in the labor force (working or looking for work), was well below the national average. A high share of the city’s population was on public assistance. And, New York City reputedly had a large share of its workforce employed by the government. The latter point was always an exaggeration – if New York’s tax dollars went anywhere to a greater extent that elsewhere, they went to those retired from public service not those actively providing public services, and to the large, government-funded “non-profit” health and social service sector. Recent data from the 2006 American Community Survey (ACS – see attached spreadsheets), however, show that New York’s status as a city of non-workers may be disappearing as a “welfare generation” passes on. And dependence on government and government-funded employment is, in fact, a characteristic of the suburbs and Upstate New York, not New York City.

Is New York City Still the City That Doesn’t Work?

|

From the late 1960s to the early 1990s, New York City could be characterized as the “city that doesn’t work.” Reversing a historic pattern that had prevailed until that time, the share of NYC adults employed, or even in the labor force (working or looking for work), was well below the national average. A high share of the city’s population was on public assistance. And, New York City reputedly had a large share of its workforce employed by the government. The latter point was always an exaggeration – if New York’s tax dollars went anywhere to a greater extent that elsewhere, they went to those retired from public service not those actively providing public services, and to the large, government-funded “non-profit” health and social service sector. Recent data from the 2006 American Community Survey (ACS – see attached spreadsheets), however, show that New York’s status as a city of non-workers may be disappearing as a “welfare generation” passes on. And dependence on government and government-funded employment is, in fact, a characteristic of the suburbs and Upstate New York, not New York City.

Is New York City Still the City That Doesn’t Work?

|

From the late 1960s to the early 1990s, New York City could be characterized as the “city that doesn’t work.” Reversing a historic pattern that had prevailed until that time, the share of NYC adults employed, or even in the labor force (working or looking for work), was well below the national average. A high share of the city’s population was on public assistance. And, New York City reputedly had a large share of its workforce employed by the government. The latter point was always an exaggeration – if New York’s tax dollars went anywhere to a greater extent that elsewhere, they went to those retired from public service not those actively providing public services, and to the large, government-funded “non-profit” health and social service sector. Recent data from the 2006 American Community Survey (ACS – see attached spreadsheets), however, show that New York’s status as a city of non-workers may be disappearing as a “welfare generation” passes on. And dependence on government and government-funded employment is, in fact, a characteristic of the suburbs and Upstate New York, not New York City.

Spitzer Incompetence

|

What does it say about Governor Spitzer and his team that the best defenses of his actions on the issue of driver licenses & “troopergate” were in newspapers – and not articulated by them.?

I refer to Bill Hammond in the Daily News regarding the licenses.

Here is the highlight of Hammond’s defense, which points to facts that I have no heard Spitzer or his aides state –

DMV offices will not be handing out licenses willy-nilly to anyone who shows up with a Mexican or Saudi Arabian birth certificate. People who lack a Social Security number will have to produce, at a minimum, a valid, up-to-date passport with photo – which the DMV will check for authenticity with special scanning machines. They must also provide backup documentation of their ID and prove they live in New York. And Spitzer is ordering the DMV to use photo-comparison software to make sure one person cannot get more than one license.

McCain Enable (Revised)

|

The first candidate for whom I ever voted in a presidential primary was a member of the Church of Latter Days Saints of Jesus Christ (LDS, aka the Mormons); although he had but one eye, I’m not sure I’ve ever found anyone since whose vision so impressed me. His name was Morris Udall, he was a congressman from Arizona, and his impact on environmental legislation alone has changed for the better the lives of every American. As Doonesbury’s Jimmy Thudpucker said at the time “He might be obscure, this man with a cure, an other, but brother, he’s pure.”

There are many reasons to snicker at Mitt Romney, and I join with all those on the right, left and center who chose to cast an amused eye (or even two) on his empty suit (two sizes smaller than the one unoccupied by his rival, Fred Thompson); those clothes truly have no emperor. But, when asked to join my enemies on the religious right, or my friends on the secular left, in looking askance at him because of the religion with which he chooses to affiliate, I am somewhat less than comfortable.

Day of A-Tone

|

On Erev Yom Kippur, when Jews around the world are busy forsaking the worldly to the extent of giving up food, which, not being for free, is far more precious to us than air, I topped off my Kol Nidre service with an episode of “Real Time with Bill Maher”.

The evening’s first interview featured a testy exchange between Maher and Michael Scheuer, author of “Marching Toward Hell: America and Islam After Iraq”. Finishing the interview, Maher introduced his panel, and began with this question:

BILL MAHER: Okay. So, did anything Mr. Scheuer said upset anybody as much as the comments on Israel upset me?

Another Shot in the Generational War

|

Bloomberg (the company not the Mayor) reports that under the new agreement between General Motors and the United Auto Workers, costs will be cut primarily through lower pay and benefits for newly hired workers. General Motors is going down the tubes because the union successfully demanded too much compensation for too little work — retirees vastly outnumber workers — while the "who you know not what you know" managers that followed those who built the company paid themselves royally while failing to innovate and running the company into the ground. So sacrifices had to be made. But they were not made equally. Like our elected officials and public employee unions, GM and the UAW decided to preserve existing perks and privileges for those who have them, while ensuring the next generation will be worse off even as they must do a better job.

Another Shot in the Generational War

|

Bloomberg (the company not the Mayor) reports that under the new agreement between General Motors and the United Auto Workers, costs will be cut primarily through lower pay and benefits for newly hired workers. General Motors is going down the tubes because the union successfully demanded too much compensation for too little work — retirees vastly outnumber workers — while the "who you know not what you know" managers that followed those who built the company paid themselves royally while failing to innovate and running the company into the ground. So sacrifices had to be made. But they were not made equally. Like our elected officials and public employee unions, GM and the UAW decided to preserve existing perks and privileges for those who have them, while ensuring the next generation will be worse off even as they must do a better job.

Another Shot in the Generational War

|

Bloomberg (the company not the Mayor) reports that under the new agreement between General Motors and the United Auto Workers, costs will be cut primarily through lower pay and benefits for newly hired workers. General Motors is going down the tubes because the union successfully demanded too much compensation for too little work — retirees vastly outnumber workers — while the "who you know not what you know" managers that followed those who built the company paid themselves royally while failing to innovate and running the company into the ground. So sacrifices had to be made. But they were not made equally. Like our elected officials and public employee unions, GM and the UAW decided to preserve existing perks and privileges for those who have them, while ensuring the next generation will be worse off even as they must do a better job.

Another Shot in the Generational War

|

Bloomberg (the company not the Mayor) reports that under the new agreement between General Motors and the United Auto Workers, costs will be cut primarily through lower pay and benefits for newly hired workers. General Motors is going down the tubes because the union successfully demanded too much compensation for too little work — retirees vastly outnumber workers — while the "who you know not what you know" managers that followed those who built the company paid themselves royally while failing to innovate and running the company into the ground. So sacrifices had to be made. But they were not made equally. Like our elected officials and public employee unions, GM and the UAW decided to preserve existing perks and privileges for those who have them, while ensuring the next generation will be worse off even as they must do a better job.