Thus far, my equity and eligibility posts have reviewed public policies that direct, attempt to direct, or pretend to direct public benefits to the less well off, or to those most in need. Yet government eligibility rules have often directed public benefits, services and protections to the better off, not the worst off, with not only “conservative” and Republicans but also “egalitarian” Democrats in support. And the policy of providing benefits to the better off hasn’t been limited to obscure, limited-cost programs; it has been characteristic of the history of the most extensive and expensive public programs in the country. Over the past century and a half, many now universal or near universal benefits and protections such as public education, Social Security, unemployment insurance, and the minimum wage were offered first to the organized and influential, then to population at large, and finally to the least well off – the poor, the sick, the disabled, and minorities. The better off, in short, were the “thin end of the wedge,” those with the political clout to get a public benefit created, who later felt a duty to offer the same benefit to others. Until more recently the government, and the tax burden, reached some kind of maximum/equilibrium and the march to universal benefits stopped, leaving inequities in its wake. No one feels much duty to others anymore, even if they are receiving benefits themselves.
Category: News and Opinion
Thin Edge of the Wedge
|Thus far, my equity and eligibility posts have reviewed public policies that direct, attempt to direct, or pretend to direct public benefits to the less well off, or to those most in need. Yet government eligibility rules have often directed public benefits, services and protections to the better off, not the worst off, with not only “conservative” and Republicans but also “egalitarian” Democrats in support. And the policy of providing benefits to the better off hasn’t been limited to obscure, limited-cost programs; it has been characteristic of the history of the most extensive and expensive public programs in the country. Over the past century and a half, many now universal or near universal benefits and protections such as public education, Social Security, unemployment insurance, and the minimum wage were offered first to the organized and influential, then to population at large, and finally to the least well off – the poor, the sick, the disabled, and minorities. The better off, in short, were the “thin end of the wedge,” those with the political clout to get a public benefit created, who later felt a duty to offer the same benefit to others. Until more recently the government, and the tax burden, reached some kind of maximum/equilibrium and the march to universal benefits stopped, leaving inequities in its wake. No one feels much duty to others anymore, even if they are receiving benefits themselves.
Thin Edge of the Wedge
|Thus far, my equity and eligibility posts have reviewed public policies that direct, attempt to direct, or pretend to direct public benefits to the less well off, or to those most in need. Yet government eligibility rules have often directed public benefits, services and protections to the better off, not the worst off, with not only “conservative” and Republicans but also “egalitarian” Democrats in support. And the policy of providing benefits to the better off hasn’t been limited to obscure, limited-cost programs; it has been characteristic of the history of the most extensive and expensive public programs in the country. Over the past century and a half, many now universal or near universal benefits and protections such as public education, Social Security, unemployment insurance, and the minimum wage were offered first to the organized and influential, then to population at large, and finally to the least well off – the poor, the sick, the disabled, and minorities. The better off, in short, were the “thin end of the wedge,” those with the political clout to get a public benefit created, who later felt a duty to offer the same benefit to others. Until more recently the government, and the tax burden, reached some kind of maximum/equilibrium and the march to universal benefits stopped, leaving inequities in its wake. No one feels much duty to others anymore, even if they are receiving benefits themselves.
Thin Edge of the Wedge
|Thus far, my equity and eligibility posts have reviewed public policies that direct, attempt to direct, or pretend to direct public benefits to the less well off, or to those most in need. Yet government eligibility rules have often directed public benefits, services and protections to the better off, not the worst off, with not only “conservative” and Republicans but also “egalitarian” Democrats in support. And the policy of providing benefits to the better off hasn’t been limited to obscure, limited-cost programs; it has been characteristic of the history of the most extensive and expensive public programs in the country. Over the past century and a half, many now universal or near universal benefits and protections such as public education, Social Security, unemployment insurance, and the minimum wage were offered first to the organized and influential, then to population at large, and finally to the least well off – the poor, the sick, the disabled, and minorities. The better off, in short, were the “thin end of the wedge,” those with the political clout to get a public benefit created, who later felt a duty to offer the same benefit to others. Until more recently the government, and the tax burden, reached some kind of maximum/equilibrium and the march to universal benefits stopped, leaving inequities in its wake. No one feels much duty to others anymore, even if they are receiving benefits themselves.
Setting The Standard
|The non-decision to implement a “hope no one shows up” non-policy, discussed in my prior post, is directly connected to the issue of standards, and to the cost of benefits per recipient. For every needs- and means-restricted benefit, there is a tradeoff between the number of beneficiaries that can be served and the amount that can be spent on each. This tradeoff is being made, generally without a direct acknowledgement that it is being made, in almost every major category of public service, from education to health care. And liberals and Democrats, in pushing to enact expensive benefits, often end up agreeing to serve some people but not others – others who are just as in need, or more in need, than those who receive the benefits. As the United States, with the most expensive health care in the world but also the most uninsured people in the developed world, finally acknowledges how bad its health care finance system is, the issue of standards will clearly move to the forefront. Clearly the U.S. can afford basic health care, even good health care, for everyone just by using what the government is already spending. But that would mean some beneficiaries would have to give up extravagant health care, and it is those with extravagant health benefits, not the uninsured, who have political power.
Setting The Standard
|The non-decision to implement a “hope no one shows up” non-policy, discussed in my prior post, is directly connected to the issue of standards, and to the cost of benefits per recipient. For every needs- and means-restricted benefit, there is a tradeoff between the number of beneficiaries that can be served and the amount that can be spent on each. This tradeoff is being made, generally without a direct acknowledgement that it is being made, in almost every major category of public service, from education to health care. And liberals and Democrats, in pushing to enact expensive benefits, often end up agreeing to serve some people but not others – others who are just as in need, or more in need, than those who receive the benefits. As the United States, with the most expensive health care in the world but also the most uninsured people in the developed world, finally acknowledges how bad its health care finance system is, the issue of standards will clearly move to the forefront. Clearly the U.S. can afford basic health care, even good health care, for everyone just by using what the government is already spending. But that would mean some beneficiaries would have to give up extravagant health care, and it is those with extravagant health benefits, not the uninsured, who have political power.
Setting The Standard
|The non-decision to implement a “hope no one shows up” non-policy, discussed in my prior post, is directly connected to the issue of standards, and to the cost of benefits per recipient. For every needs- and means-restricted benefit, there is a tradeoff between the number of beneficiaries that can be served and the amount that can be spent on each. This tradeoff is being made, generally without a direct acknowledgement that it is being made, in almost every major category of public service, from education to health care. And liberals and Democrats, in pushing to enact expensive benefits, often end up agreeing to serve some people but not others – others who are just as in need, or more in need, than those who receive the benefits. As the United States, with the most expensive health care in the world but also the most uninsured people in the developed world, finally acknowledges how bad its health care finance system is, the issue of standards will clearly move to the forefront. Clearly the U.S. can afford basic health care, even good health care, for everyone just by using what the government is already spending. But that would mean some beneficiaries would have to give up extravagant health care, and it is those with extravagant health benefits, not the uninsured, who have political power.
Setting The Standard
|The non-decision to implement a “hope no one shows up” non-policy, discussed in my prior post, is directly connected to the issue of standards, and to the cost of benefits per recipient. For every needs- and means-restricted benefit, there is a tradeoff between the number of beneficiaries that can be served and the amount that can be spent on each. This tradeoff is being made, generally without a direct acknowledgement that it is being made, in almost every major category of public service, from education to health care. And liberals and Democrats, in pushing to enact expensive benefits, often end up agreeing to serve some people but not others – others who are just as in need, or more in need, than those who receive the benefits. As the United States, with the most expensive health care in the world but also the most uninsured people in the developed world, finally acknowledges how bad its health care finance system is, the issue of standards will clearly move to the forefront. Clearly the U.S. can afford basic health care, even good health care, for everyone just by using what the government is already spending. But that would mean some beneficiaries would have to give up extravagant health care, and it is those with extravagant health benefits, not the uninsured, who have political power.
Setting The Standard
|The non-decision to implement a “hope no one shows up” non-policy, discussed in my prior post, is directly connected to the issue of standards, and to the cost of benefits per recipient. For every needs- and means-restricted benefit, there is a tradeoff between the number of beneficiaries that can be served and the amount that can be spent on each. This tradeoff is being made, generally without a direct acknowledgement that it is being made, in almost every major category of public service, from education to health care. And liberals and Democrats, in pushing to enact expensive benefits, often end up agreeing to serve some people but not others – others who are just as in need, or more in need, than those who receive the benefits. As the United States, with the most expensive health care in the world but also the most uninsured people in the developed world, finally acknowledges how bad its health care finance system is, the issue of standards will clearly move to the forefront. Clearly the U.S. can afford basic health care, even good health care, for everyone just by using what the government is already spending. But that would mean some beneficiaries would have to give up extravagant health care, and it is those with extravagant health benefits, not the uninsured, who have political power.
Setting The Standard
|The non-decision to implement a “hope no one shows up” non-policy, discussed in my prior post, is directly connected to the issue of standards, and to the cost of benefits per recipient. For every needs- and means-restricted benefit, there is a tradeoff between the number of beneficiaries that can be served and the amount that can be spent on each. This tradeoff is being made, generally without a direct acknowledgement that it is being made, in almost every major category of public service, from education to health care. And liberals and Democrats, in pushing to enact expensive benefits, often end up agreeing to serve some people but not others – others who are just as in need, or more in need, than those who receive the benefits. As the United States, with the most expensive health care in the world but also the most uninsured people in the developed world, finally acknowledges how bad its health care finance system is, the issue of standards will clearly move to the forefront. Clearly the U.S. can afford basic health care, even good health care, for everyone just by using what the government is already spending. But that would mean some beneficiaries would have to give up extravagant health care, and it is those with extravagant health benefits, not the uninsured, who have political power.
