The Brooklyn Story Painfully Continues

|

When I first wrote the “Brooklyn Story”, I figured that two parts would take care of this issue (residency), this time around: I was wrong. The story painfully continues. I talked about three individuals (and others by association and implication) whose residencies have been questioned by many in Brooklyn. I hoped to show that residency laws are ambiguous and nebulous, and that in political races both the spirit and letter of the law are usually violated; especially when applied against those not connected to the powers that be. Especially when used against insurgents challenging elected officials. I have always been outraged by this; it’s unfair and unjust.

Last week, the court challenge against Judge Shawndya Simpson’s residency started in a Brooklyn court. It was hastily moved to a court in Queens. For those who came into the room late, Ms. Simpson is running against Judge Diana Johnson, in a contest for the second Brooklyn Surrogate spot. Judge Margarita Lopez holds the other. Last Friday 17th August, 2007, Judge Peter O’Donoghue ruled that Ms. Simpson did in fact live in Brooklyn; tomorrow however, her opponents are going to the Appellate Court in order to reverse that ruling. Please remember that Ms. Simpson is the candidate being backed by the Brooklyn Democrat’s county organization. Note also that the same organization has in the past, backed surrogate judges who have been convicted- or removed under clouds of suspicion and corruption- over the last 30 years plus. Please remember also, that it was NYC Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia who called the Surrogate Court: “the piggy bank for elected officials and politicians.” They all see it as a cookie jar of sorts.

“Hope No One Shows Up”

|

The constant liberalization and restriction of eligibility, and increase and decrease in personal scrutiny, under means- and need-restricted programs is the off-the-books, under-the-radar outcome of an ongoing struggle between “liberals,” who want many people eligible for expensive services (often because they earn a living providing those services) and “conservatives,” who do not require services and do want to pay taxes to help those who do require them. In economic expansions, when more services may be offered without a tax increase, advocates often demand, and receive, more extensive services for more people. In economic downturns, when falling tax revenues lead to budget crises, there is generally a sudden finding of “waste, fraud and abuse.” In all times, however, politicians often compromise by gross hypocrisy. While focused on the needs of particular group (supported by organized advocates), they prove their compassion by passing laws that, in theory, make many people eligible for extensive services and benefits. But during the budget process, when different needs and priorities are in competition, resources are scarce, and tradeoffs must be made, they save money by not providing enough to cover everyone theoretically eligible to get all the benefits they are theoretically entitled to. Having claimed credit for making a benefit available, both Republicans and Democrats “hope no one shows up” to claim it.

“Hope No One Shows Up”

|

The constant liberalization and restriction of eligibility, and increase and decrease in personal scrutiny, under means- and need-restricted programs is the off-the-books, under-the-radar outcome of an ongoing struggle between “liberals,” who want many people eligible for expensive services (often because they earn a living providing those services) and “conservatives,” who do not require services and do want to pay taxes to help those who do require them. In economic expansions, when more services may be offered without a tax increase, advocates often demand, and receive, more extensive services for more people. In economic downturns, when falling tax revenues lead to budget crises, there is generally a sudden finding of “waste, fraud and abuse.” In all times, however, politicians often compromise by gross hypocrisy. While focused on the needs of particular group (supported by organized advocates), they prove their compassion by passing laws that, in theory, make many people eligible for extensive services and benefits. But during the budget process, when different needs and priorities are in competition, resources are scarce, and tradeoffs must be made, they save money by not providing enough to cover everyone theoretically eligible to get all the benefits they are theoretically entitled to. Having claimed credit for making a benefit available, both Republicans and Democrats “hope no one shows up” to claim it.

“Hope No One Shows Up”

|

The constant liberalization and restriction of eligibility, and increase and decrease in personal scrutiny, under means- and need-restricted programs is the off-the-books, under-the-radar outcome of an ongoing struggle between “liberals,” who want many people eligible for expensive services (often because they earn a living providing those services) and “conservatives,” who do not require services and do want to pay taxes to help those who do require them. In economic expansions, when more services may be offered without a tax increase, advocates often demand, and receive, more extensive services for more people. In economic downturns, when falling tax revenues lead to budget crises, there is generally a sudden finding of “waste, fraud and abuse.” In all times, however, politicians often compromise by gross hypocrisy. While focused on the needs of particular group (supported by organized advocates), they prove their compassion by passing laws that, in theory, make many people eligible for extensive services and benefits. But during the budget process, when different needs and priorities are in competition, resources are scarce, and tradeoffs must be made, they save money by not providing enough to cover everyone theoretically eligible to get all the benefits they are theoretically entitled to. Having claimed credit for making a benefit available, both Republicans and Democrats “hope no one shows up” to claim it.

“Hope No One Shows Up”

|

The constant liberalization and restriction of eligibility, and increase and decrease in personal scrutiny, under means- and need-restricted programs is the off-the-books, under-the-radar outcome of an ongoing struggle between “liberals,” who want many people eligible for expensive services (often because they earn a living providing those services) and “conservatives,” who do not require services and do want to pay taxes to help those who do require them. In economic expansions, when more services may be offered without a tax increase, advocates often demand, and receive, more extensive services for more people. In economic downturns, when falling tax revenues lead to budget crises, there is generally a sudden finding of “waste, fraud and abuse.” In all times, however, politicians often compromise by gross hypocrisy. While focused on the needs of particular group (supported by organized advocates), they prove their compassion by passing laws that, in theory, make many people eligible for extensive services and benefits. But during the budget process, when different needs and priorities are in competition, resources are scarce, and tradeoffs must be made, they save money by not providing enough to cover everyone theoretically eligible to get all the benefits they are theoretically entitled to. Having claimed credit for making a benefit available, both Republicans and Democrats “hope no one shows up” to claim it.

“Hope No One Shows Up”

|

The constant liberalization and restriction of eligibility, and increase and decrease in personal scrutiny, under means- and need-restricted programs is the off-the-books, under-the-radar outcome of an ongoing struggle between “liberals,” who want many people eligible for expensive services (often because they earn a living providing those services) and “conservatives,” who do not require services and do want to pay taxes to help those who do require them. In economic expansions, when more services may be offered without a tax increase, advocates often demand, and receive, more extensive services for more people. In economic downturns, when falling tax revenues lead to budget crises, there is generally a sudden finding of “waste, fraud and abuse.” In all times, however, politicians often compromise by gross hypocrisy. While focused on the needs of particular group (supported by organized advocates), they prove their compassion by passing laws that, in theory, make many people eligible for extensive services and benefits. But during the budget process, when different needs and priorities are in competition, resources are scarce, and tradeoffs must be made, they save money by not providing enough to cover everyone theoretically eligible to get all the benefits they are theoretically entitled to. Having claimed credit for making a benefit available, both Republicans and Democrats “hope no one shows up” to claim it.

“Hope No One Shows Up”

|

The constant liberalization and restriction of eligibility, and increase and decrease in personal scrutiny, under means- and need-restricted programs is the off-the-books, under-the-radar outcome of an ongoing struggle between “liberals,” who want many people eligible for expensive services (often because they earn a living providing those services) and “conservatives,” who do not require services and do want to pay taxes to help those who do require them. In economic expansions, when more services may be offered without a tax increase, advocates often demand, and receive, more extensive services for more people. In economic downturns, when falling tax revenues lead to budget crises, there is generally a sudden finding of “waste, fraud and abuse.” In all times, however, politicians often compromise by gross hypocrisy. While focused on the needs of particular group (supported by organized advocates), they prove their compassion by passing laws that, in theory, make many people eligible for extensive services and benefits. But during the budget process, when different needs and priorities are in competition, resources are scarce, and tradeoffs must be made, they save money by not providing enough to cover everyone theoretically eligible to get all the benefits they are theoretically entitled to. Having claimed credit for making a benefit available, both Republicans and Democrats “hope no one shows up” to claim it.

The Hottest Tickets in Brooklyn Right Now

|

Earlier in the presidential campaign of Barack Obama, his people believed that New York was a write-off; they felt that Hilary Rodham-Clinton was a lock to win most if not all the convention delegates coming out of New York. To the shrewd political analyst this observation probably made a lot of sense, but sometimes politics defy common sense, and at other times common sense defies conventional political thinking. What is shaping in Brooklyn is a case in point.

As soon as Barack Obama officially announced his presidential pursuit last winter, a group of young idealists came together shortly after to form an organization called: “Brooklyn for Barack Obama”. Almost immediately they hit the street; registering voters, recruiting volunteers, staging rallies, canvassing, politicking, visibly dealing with issues, spreading the Obama message and pushing their candidate. Despite the knowledge that Obama’s national campaign was reluctant to invest in a New York challenge, these young political neophytes, have been undeterred in their objective to deliver Brooklyn’s democrats to the Obama delegate count.

Age, Means and Needs: Fair in Theory, Hard to Implement In Practice

|

When one examines public policies to ensure the care of the poor and those with special needs, and goes beyond the rhetoric about “racism,” “welfare queens,” “malingerers,” “big corporations,” insurance companies, “big government,” “compassion” and “rights,” one finds difficult choices and high stakes. The choices are often made by low level, underpaid public officials who cannot possibly have the information required to make them fairly and correctly, and who are at any moment subject to political blame for injustice and suffering, for waste, fraud and taxes. People don’t like to be forced to confront such difficult choices. And you don’t attract votes, viewers or readers by forcing them to.

Age, Means and Needs: Fair in Theory, Hard to Implement In Practice

|

When one examines public policies to ensure the care of the poor and those with special needs, and goes beyond the rhetoric about “racism,” “welfare queens,” “malingerers,” “big corporations,” insurance companies, “big government,” “compassion” and “rights,” one finds difficult choices and high stakes. The choices are often made by low level, underpaid public officials who cannot possibly have the information required to make them fairly and correctly, and who are at any moment subject to political blame for injustice and suffering, for waste, fraud and taxes. People don’t like to be forced to confront such difficult choices. And you don’t attract votes, viewers or readers by forcing them to.