Per Student Revenues and Expenditures in FY 2002 and FY 2005: A Little Good News and Lot of Bad News for NYC

|

Through the 1990s, New York City’s per student public school revenues and expenditures were below the national average if adjusted for the cost of living using the modest method I prefer (see the end of the prior post). In Fiscal 2002, however, NYC’s spending per student was $10,882 in cost of living-adjusted $2005, above the national average of $10,084. Unfortunately, the city’s public school revenues per student were only $9,435 at the time, well below the national average of $9,879, as the city borrowed with abandon and kept taxes low during former Mayor Giuliani’s second term. With Mayor Bloomberg making education a top priority, by FY2005 an additional breakthrough had occurred as the city’s revenues per student, adjusted for the cost of living, reached $11,564 that year, above the national average of $10,339. That, I suppose is good news. Almost everything else I discovered about changes between FY 2002 and FY 2005, however, is bad news, with much of it based on decisions made before FY 2002, or subsequently by former Governor Pataki and the New York State legislature. Through FY 2005 Mayor Bloomberg’s fiscal imprint was, in reality modest.

Per Student Revenues and Expenditures in FY 2002 and FY 2005: A Little Good News and Lot of Bad News for NYC

|

Through the 1990s, New York City’s per student public school revenues and expenditures were below the national average if adjusted for the cost of living using the modest method I prefer (see the end of the prior post). In Fiscal 2002, however, NYC’s spending per student was $10,882 in cost of living-adjusted $2005, above the national average of $10,084. Unfortunately, the city’s public school revenues per student were only $9,435 at the time, well below the national average of $9,879, as the city borrowed with abandon and kept taxes low during former Mayor Giuliani’s second term. With Mayor Bloomberg making education a top priority, by FY2005 an additional breakthrough had occurred as the city’s revenues per student, adjusted for the cost of living, reached $11,564 that year, above the national average of $10,339. That, I suppose is good news. Almost everything else I discovered about changes between FY 2002 and FY 2005, however, is bad news, with much of it based on decisions made before FY 2002, or subsequently by former Governor Pataki and the New York State legislature. Through FY 2005 Mayor Bloomberg’s fiscal imprint was, in reality modest.

Per Student Revenues and Expenditures in FY 2002 and FY 2005: A Little Good News and Lot of Bad News for NYC

|

Through the 1990s, New York City’s per student public school revenues and expenditures were below the national average if adjusted for the cost of living using the modest method I prefer (see the end of the prior post). In Fiscal 2002, however, NYC’s spending per student was $10,882 in cost of living-adjusted $2005, above the national average of $10,084. Unfortunately, the city’s public school revenues per student were only $9,435 at the time, well below the national average of $9,879, as the city borrowed with abandon and kept taxes low during former Mayor Giuliani’s second term. With Mayor Bloomberg making education a top priority, by FY2005 an additional breakthrough had occurred as the city’s revenues per student, adjusted for the cost of living, reached $11,564 that year, above the national average of $10,339. That, I suppose is good news. Almost everything else I discovered about changes between FY 2002 and FY 2005, however, is bad news, with much of it based on decisions made before FY 2002, or subsequently by former Governor Pataki and the New York State legislature. Through FY 2005 Mayor Bloomberg’s fiscal imprint was, in reality modest.

Per Student Revenues and Expenditures in FY 2002 and FY 2005: A Little Good News and Lot of Bad News for NYC

|

Through the 1990s, New York City’s per student public school revenues and expenditures were below the national average if adjusted for the cost of living using the modest method I prefer (see the end of the prior post). In Fiscal 2002, however, NYC’s spending per student was $10,882 in cost of living-adjusted $2005, above the national average of $10,084. Unfortunately, the city’s public school revenues per student were only $9,435 at the time, well below the national average of $9,879, as the city borrowed with abandon and kept taxes low during former Mayor Giuliani’s second term. With Mayor Bloomberg making education a top priority, by FY2005 an additional breakthrough had occurred as the city’s revenues per student, adjusted for the cost of living, reached $11,564 that year, above the national average of $10,339. That, I suppose is good news. Almost everything else I discovered about changes between FY 2002 and FY 2005, however, is bad news, with much of it based on decisions made before FY 2002, or subsequently by former Governor Pataki and the New York State legislature. Through FY 2005 Mayor Bloomberg’s fiscal imprint was, in reality modest.

NYC Public Education Finance: The Streak Continues

|

In FY 2002, thanks to 2.5% inflation-adjusted decline in the personal income of New York City residents according to the latest estimates from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending rose to 4.57% of that personal income, within rounding error of the U.S. average of 4.63%. I thought, and not for the first time, that the city’s public school spending might actually exceed the national average as a share of income in some subsequent year. But it was not to be. As in the early 1990s, government budget reductions lagged the reduction in the tax base, but once they kicked in and personal income began to recover, the city’s public school spending fell as a share of personal income. As I showed earlier based on another data source, the city’s share of state education funding (direct and back-door funding under programs like STAR) was also cut. Meanwhile, spending in the rest of the state stayed at sky-high levels relative to personal income. In fiscal 2005, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending had fallen to 4.28% of city residents’ personal income, 7.5% below the national average and 33.7% below the average for the rest of New York State.

NYC Public Education Finance: The Streak Continues

|

In FY 2002, thanks to 2.5% inflation-adjusted decline in the personal income of New York City residents according to the latest estimates from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending rose to 4.57% of that personal income, within rounding error of the U.S. average of 4.63%. I thought, and not for the first time, that the city’s public school spending might actually exceed the national average as a share of income in some subsequent year. But it was not to be. As in the early 1990s, government budget reductions lagged the reduction in the tax base, but once they kicked in and personal income began to recover, the city’s public school spending fell as a share of personal income. As I showed earlier based on another data source, the city’s share of state education funding (direct and back-door funding under programs like STAR) was also cut. Meanwhile, spending in the rest of the state stayed at sky-high levels relative to personal income. In fiscal 2005, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending had fallen to 4.28% of city residents’ personal income, 7.5% below the national average and 33.7% below the average for the rest of New York State.

NYC Public Education Finance: The Streak Continues

|

In FY 2002, thanks to 2.5% inflation-adjusted decline in the personal income of New York City residents according to the latest estimates from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending rose to 4.57% of that personal income, within rounding error of the U.S. average of 4.63%. I thought, and not for the first time, that the city’s public school spending might actually exceed the national average as a share of income in some subsequent year. But it was not to be. As in the early 1990s, government budget reductions lagged the reduction in the tax base, but once they kicked in and personal income began to recover, the city’s public school spending fell as a share of personal income. As I showed earlier based on another data source, the city’s share of state education funding (direct and back-door funding under programs like STAR) was also cut. Meanwhile, spending in the rest of the state stayed at sky-high levels relative to personal income. In fiscal 2005, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending had fallen to 4.28% of city residents’ personal income, 7.5% below the national average and 33.7% below the average for the rest of New York State.

NYC Public Education Finance: The Streak Continues

|

In FY 2002, thanks to 2.5% inflation-adjusted decline in the personal income of New York City residents according to the latest estimates from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending rose to 4.57% of that personal income, within rounding error of the U.S. average of 4.63%. I thought, and not for the first time, that the city’s public school spending might actually exceed the national average as a share of income in some subsequent year. But it was not to be. As in the early 1990s, government budget reductions lagged the reduction in the tax base, but once they kicked in and personal income began to recover, the city’s public school spending fell as a share of personal income. As I showed earlier based on another data source, the city’s share of state education funding (direct and back-door funding under programs like STAR) was also cut. Meanwhile, spending in the rest of the state stayed at sky-high levels relative to personal income. In fiscal 2005, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending had fallen to 4.28% of city residents’ personal income, 7.5% below the national average and 33.7% below the average for the rest of New York State.

NYC Public Education Finance: The Streak Continues

|

In FY 2002, thanks to 2.5% inflation-adjusted decline in the personal income of New York City residents according to the latest estimates from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending rose to 4.57% of that personal income, within rounding error of the U.S. average of 4.63%. I thought, and not for the first time, that the city’s public school spending might actually exceed the national average as a share of income in some subsequent year. But it was not to be. As in the early 1990s, government budget reductions lagged the reduction in the tax base, but once they kicked in and personal income began to recover, the city’s public school spending fell as a share of personal income. As I showed earlier based on another data source, the city’s share of state education funding (direct and back-door funding under programs like STAR) was also cut. Meanwhile, spending in the rest of the state stayed at sky-high levels relative to personal income. In fiscal 2005, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending had fallen to 4.28% of city residents’ personal income, 7.5% below the national average and 33.7% below the average for the rest of New York State.

NYC Public Education Finance: The Streak Continues

|

In FY 2002, thanks to 2.5% inflation-adjusted decline in the personal income of New York City residents according to the latest estimates from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending rose to 4.57% of that personal income, within rounding error of the U.S. average of 4.63%. I thought, and not for the first time, that the city’s public school spending might actually exceed the national average as a share of income in some subsequent year. But it was not to be. As in the early 1990s, government budget reductions lagged the reduction in the tax base, but once they kicked in and personal income began to recover, the city’s public school spending fell as a share of personal income. As I showed earlier based on another data source, the city’s share of state education funding (direct and back-door funding under programs like STAR) was also cut. Meanwhile, spending in the rest of the state stayed at sky-high levels relative to personal income. In fiscal 2005, New York City’s elementary and secondary public school spending had fallen to 4.28% of city residents’ personal income, 7.5% below the national average and 33.7% below the average for the rest of New York State.