School Choice and Stress

|

The New York Times had an interesting article today on school choice within the public schools. “Under Mr. Klein, choice has increased exponentially,” the Times said. “Giving people choices is always empowering and almost always will lead to better outcomes for kids,” the Chancellor is quoted as saying. “Choices could indicate when an undesirable school should close.” Yet far from feeling empowered, parents are feeling frantic according to the newspaper. And less affluent, low income parents and their children will be left behind. Why? One sentence captures the problem. “While some parents say they are thrilled to have such a rich menu of options, others complain that it is the schools — not families — who do the choosing.” That’s the reality. The limited, though hopefully growing (some who post here say no) number of schools were a decent education is on offer are deciding which children they will deign to educate. Or it is being decided by chance, or other procedures. The other schools aren’t going to close. They are going to get the kids who aren’t accepted or who lose the lottery.

School Choice and Stress

|

The New York Times had an interesting article today on school choice within the public schools. “Under Mr. Klein, choice has increased exponentially,” the Times said. “Giving people choices is always empowering and almost always will lead to better outcomes for kids,” the Chancellor is quoted as saying. “Choices could indicate when an undesirable school should close.” Yet far from feeling empowered, parents are feeling frantic according to the newspaper. And less affluent, low income parents and their children will be left behind. Why? One sentence captures the problem. “While some parents say they are thrilled to have such a rich menu of options, others complain that it is the schools — not families — who do the choosing.” That’s the reality. The limited, though hopefully growing (some who post here say no) number of schools were a decent education is on offer are deciding which children they will deign to educate. Or it is being decided by chance, or other procedures. The other schools aren’t going to close. They are going to get the kids who aren’t accepted or who lose the lottery.

NYC Public School Spending: Way Up Compared With The U.S.

|

In a prior post, I showed how far New York City lagged beyond the rest of New York State in public school spending in FY 2005, with a conservative cost of living adjustment applied to Downstate expenditures. Using data from the U.S. Census Bureau for Fiscal Years (FY) 1997 and 2004, however, we find that inflation-adjusted per-student current expenditures for the city’s schools increased 46.7% from the former year to the latter. And whereas the city’s per child current spending was 2.3% below the national average in FY1997, it was 19.2% above average in FY2004. The spreadsheet is attached, and I'd rather have you download that than read the rest of this post. Once you have, to compare your explanations to mine, my overview of the breakdown by type of spending follows.

NYC Public School Spending: Way Up Compared With The U.S.

|

In a prior post, I showed how far New York City lagged beyond the rest of New York State in public school spending in FY 2005, with a conservative cost of living adjustment applied to Downstate expenditures. Using data from the U.S. Census Bureau for Fiscal Years (FY) 1997 and 2004, however, we find that inflation-adjusted per-student current expenditures for the city’s schools increased 46.7% from the former year to the latter. And whereas the city’s per child current spending was 2.3% below the national average in FY1997, it was 19.2% above average in FY2004. The spreadsheet is attached, and I'd rather have you download that than read the rest of this post. Once you have, to compare your explanations to mine, my overview of the breakdown by type of spending follows.

NYC Public School Spending: Way Up Compared With The U.S.

|

In a prior post, I showed how far New York City lagged beyond the rest of New York State in public school spending in FY 2005, with a conservative cost of living adjustment applied to Downstate expenditures. Using data from the U.S. Census Bureau for Fiscal Years (FY) 1997 and 2004, however, we find that inflation-adjusted per-student current expenditures for the city’s schools increased 46.7% from the former year to the latter. And whereas the city’s per child current spending was 2.3% below the national average in FY1997, it was 19.2% above average in FY2004. The spreadsheet is attached, and I'd rather have you download that than read the rest of this post. Once you have, to compare your explanations to mine, my overview of the breakdown by type of spending follows.

NYC Public School Spending: Way Up Compared With The U.S.

|

In a prior post, I showed how far New York City lagged beyond the rest of New York State in public school spending in FY 2005, with a conservative cost of living adjustment applied to Downstate expenditures. Using data from the U.S. Census Bureau for Fiscal Years (FY) 1997 and 2004, however, we find that inflation-adjusted per-student current expenditures for the city’s schools increased 46.7% from the former year to the latter. And whereas the city’s per child current spending was 2.3% below the national average in FY1997, it was 19.2% above average in FY2004. The spreadsheet is attached, and I'd rather have you download that than read the rest of this post. Once you have, to compare your explanations to mine, my overview of the breakdown by type of spending follows.

NYC Public School Spending: Way Up Compared With The U.S.

|

In a prior post, I showed how far New York City lagged beyond the rest of New York State in public school spending in FY 2005, with a conservative cost of living adjustment applied to Downstate expenditures. Using data from the U.S. Census Bureau for Fiscal Years (FY) 1997 and 2004, however, we find that inflation-adjusted per-student current expenditures for the city’s schools increased 46.7% from the former year to the latter. And whereas the city’s per child current spending was 2.3% below the national average in FY1997, it was 19.2% above average in FY2004. The spreadsheet is attached, and I'd rather have you download that than read the rest of this post. Once you have, to compare your explanations to mine, my overview of the breakdown by type of spending follows.

NYC Public School Spending: Way Up Compared With The U.S.

|

In a prior post, I showed how far New York City lagged beyond the rest of New York State in public school spending in FY 2005, with a conservative cost of living adjustment applied to Downstate expenditures. Using data from the U.S. Census Bureau for Fiscal Years (FY) 1997 and 2004, however, we find that inflation-adjusted per-student current expenditures for the city’s schools increased 46.7% from the former year to the latter. And whereas the city’s per child current spending was 2.3% below the national average in FY1997, it was 19.2% above average in FY2004. The spreadsheet is attached, and I'd rather have you download that than read the rest of this post. Once you have, to compare your explanations to mine, my overview of the breakdown by type of spending follows.

The City That Doesn’t Work (Or Didn’t)

|

I recently wrote a series of essays on what I consider to be phony or exaggerated economic issues in New York State. Now I’m going to write a series of essays on the real problems, as I see them. For New York City, perhaps the biggest problem is the low share of its adults who work, or look for work. The support of the non-working is a burden the working have to carry, and to the extent that burden is concentrated on those who live in their proximity, it is a particular burden in New York. But that liability is small compared with the impact of the absence of employment on the non-employed themselves. It is one of several ways New York’s poor are less well off now than in the 1950s – though, as we shall see, better off than in the mid-1990s.

The City That Doesn’t Work (Or Didn’t)

|

I recently wrote a series of essays on what I consider to be phony or exaggerated economic issues in New York State. Now I’m going to write a series of essays on the real problems, as I see them. For New York City, perhaps the biggest problem is the low share of its adults who work, or look for work. The support of the non-working is a burden the working have to carry, and to the extent that burden is concentrated on those who live in their proximity, it is a particular burden in New York. But that liability is small compared with the impact of the absence of employment on the non-employed themselves. It is one of several ways New York’s poor are less well off now than in the 1950s – though, as we shall see, better off than in the mid-1990s.