Just because it is the national average doesn’t make it right, and it is possible that differences in local needs and conditions allow lower spending in some categories while requiring higher expenditures in others. But any deviation, in either direction, should be explained and justified. In New York, on the other hand, the winners tend to take money off the top, with (generally) state legislation guaranteeing them the first bite of the apple, with the bite adjusted upward each year. So when money becomes scarce, it is the losers who are sacrificed, including the one we have already discussed — taxpayers — who saw a big increase in their state and local tax burden as a share of income in New York City, and a smaller increase in the rest of the state, in the last recession. I once described the Campaign for Fiscal Equity lawsuit as the “battle of the losers,” pitting New York’s city and state taxpayers against the city’s children, with the winners laughing up the stands. In FY 2005 they were laughing still. In the most recent state budget battle one of the winners roared and snarled, because its bite didn’t increase as much as it felt entitled to. That is the state of play in “feudal” New York.
The Latest
The Losers: Below Average Local Government Spending in NYC in FY 2005
|Just because it is the national average doesn’t make it right, and it is possible that differences in local needs and conditions allow lower spending in some categories while requiring higher expenditures in others. But any deviation, in either direction, should be explained and justified. In New York, on the other hand, the winners tend to take money off the top, with (generally) state legislation guaranteeing them the first bite of the apple, with the bite adjusted upward each year. So when money becomes scarce, it is the losers who are sacrificed, including the one we have already discussed — taxpayers — who saw a big increase in their state and local tax burden as a share of income in New York City, and a smaller increase in the rest of the state, in the last recession. I once described the Campaign for Fiscal Equity lawsuit as the “battle of the losers,” pitting New York’s city and state taxpayers against the city’s children, with the winners laughing up the stands. In FY 2005 they were laughing still. In the most recent state budget battle one of the winners roared and snarled, because its bite didn’t increase as much as it felt entitled to. That is the state of play in “feudal” New York.
The Losers: Below Average Local Government Spending in NYC in FY 2005
|Just because it is the national average doesn’t make it right, and it is possible that differences in local needs and conditions allow lower spending in some categories while requiring higher expenditures in others. But any deviation, in either direction, should be explained and justified. In New York, on the other hand, the winners tend to take money off the top, with (generally) state legislation guaranteeing them the first bite of the apple, with the bite adjusted upward each year. So when money becomes scarce, it is the losers who are sacrificed, including the one we have already discussed — taxpayers — who saw a big increase in their state and local tax burden as a share of income in New York City, and a smaller increase in the rest of the state, in the last recession. I once described the Campaign for Fiscal Equity lawsuit as the “battle of the losers,” pitting New York’s city and state taxpayers against the city’s children, with the winners laughing up the stands. In FY 2005 they were laughing still. In the most recent state budget battle one of the winners roared and snarled, because its bite didn’t increase as much as it felt entitled to. That is the state of play in “feudal” New York.
The Losers: Below Average Local Government Spending in NYC in FY 2005
|Just because it is the national average doesn’t make it right, and it is possible that differences in local needs and conditions allow lower spending in some categories while requiring higher expenditures in others. But any deviation, in either direction, should be explained and justified. In New York, on the other hand, the winners tend to take money off the top, with (generally) state legislation guaranteeing them the first bite of the apple, with the bite adjusted upward each year. So when money becomes scarce, it is the losers who are sacrificed, including the one we have already discussed — taxpayers — who saw a big increase in their state and local tax burden as a share of income in New York City, and a smaller increase in the rest of the state, in the last recession. I once described the Campaign for Fiscal Equity lawsuit as the “battle of the losers,” pitting New York’s city and state taxpayers against the city’s children, with the winners laughing up the stands. In FY 2005 they were laughing still. In the most recent state budget battle one of the winners roared and snarled, because its bite didn’t increase as much as it felt entitled to. That is the state of play in “feudal” New York.
The Winners: Where NYC’s Public Money Went in FY 2005
|It’s Memorial Day weekend as I write this, it’s a beautiful day, and it’s tempting to save some time by just copying my post from last year on the categories of local government expenditures for which New York City and the rest of the state spend more, or less, than the national average. After all, the winners and losers don’t change much from year to year, although the losers sometimes catch up a little in good years (when other interests are sated) and fall behind more in bad years (when victims must be found). But I’ve compiled the data, so I might as well write about it, and the readers could express their gratitude by downloading the spreadsheet linked here (click on the Output tab), printing the two pages, and looking them over. For the less grateful a brief summary table may be found at the bottom of this post, and it shows that New York City spent much more than the U.S. local government average, as a share of its residents’ personal income, on interest on past debts, pension contributions, payments to the State of New York for Medicaid, and Police and Correction. As always. Local governments in the rest of New York State also spent more than average on Medicaid payments, but not to nearly the same extent, and spent about average in the other categories were NYC was high. Elementary and secondary education spending, however, was sky-high as a share of personal income in the rest of the state, but below the national average in NYC. As always.
The Winners: Where NYC’s Public Money Went in FY 2005
|It’s Memorial Day weekend as I write this, it’s a beautiful day, and it’s tempting to save some time by just copying my post from last year on the categories of local government expenditures for which New York City and the rest of the state spend more, or less, than the national average. After all, the winners and losers don’t change much from year to year, although the losers sometimes catch up a little in good years (when other interests are sated) and fall behind more in bad years (when victims must be found). But I’ve compiled the data, so I might as well write about it, and the readers could express their gratitude by downloading the spreadsheet linked here (click on the Output tab), printing the two pages, and looking them over. For the less grateful a brief summary table may be found at the bottom of this post, and it shows that New York City spent much more than the U.S. local government average, as a share of its residents’ personal income, on interest on past debts, pension contributions, payments to the State of New York for Medicaid, and Police and Correction. As always. Local governments in the rest of New York State also spent more than average on Medicaid payments, but not to nearly the same extent, and spent about average in the other categories were NYC was high. Elementary and secondary education spending, however, was sky-high as a share of personal income in the rest of the state, but below the national average in NYC. As always.
The Winners: Where NYC’s Public Money Went in FY 2005
|It’s Memorial Day weekend as I write this, it’s a beautiful day, and it’s tempting to save some time by just copying my post from last year on the categories of local government expenditures for which New York City and the rest of the state spend more, or less, than the national average. After all, the winners and losers don’t change much from year to year, although the losers sometimes catch up a little in good years (when other interests are sated) and fall behind more in bad years (when victims must be found). But I’ve compiled the data, so I might as well write about it, and the readers could express their gratitude by downloading the spreadsheet linked here (click on the Output tab), printing the two pages, and looking them over. For the less grateful a brief summary table may be found at the bottom of this post, and it shows that New York City spent much more than the U.S. local government average, as a share of its residents’ personal income, on interest on past debts, pension contributions, payments to the State of New York for Medicaid, and Police and Correction. As always. Local governments in the rest of New York State also spent more than average on Medicaid payments, but not to nearly the same extent, and spent about average in the other categories were NYC was high. Elementary and secondary education spending, however, was sky-high as a share of personal income in the rest of the state, but below the national average in NYC. As always.
The Winners: Where NYC’s Public Money Went in FY 2005
|It’s Memorial Day weekend as I write this, it’s a beautiful day, and it’s tempting to save some time by just copying my post from last year on the categories of local government expenditures for which New York City and the rest of the state spend more, or less, than the national average. After all, the winners and losers don’t change much from year to year, although the losers sometimes catch up a little in good years (when other interests are sated) and fall behind more in bad years (when victims must be found). But I’ve compiled the data, so I might as well write about it, and the readers could express their gratitude by downloading the spreadsheet linked here (click on the Output tab), printing the two pages, and looking them over. For the less grateful a brief summary table may be found at the bottom of this post, and it shows that New York City spent much more than the U.S. local government average, as a share of its residents’ personal income, on interest on past debts, pension contributions, payments to the State of New York for Medicaid, and Police and Correction. As always. Local governments in the rest of New York State also spent more than average on Medicaid payments, but not to nearly the same extent, and spent about average in the other categories were NYC was high. Elementary and secondary education spending, however, was sky-high as a share of personal income in the rest of the state, but below the national average in NYC. As always.
The Winners: Where NYC’s Public Money Went in FY 2005
|It’s Memorial Day weekend as I write this, it’s a beautiful day, and it’s tempting to save some time by just copying my post from last year on the categories of local government expenditures for which New York City and the rest of the state spend more, or less, than the national average. After all, the winners and losers don’t change much from year to year, although the losers sometimes catch up a little in good years (when other interests are sated) and fall behind more in bad years (when victims must be found). But I’ve compiled the data, so I might as well write about it, and the readers could express their gratitude by downloading the spreadsheet linked here (click on the Output tab), printing the two pages, and looking them over. For the less grateful a brief summary table may be found at the bottom of this post, and it shows that New York City spent much more than the U.S. local government average, as a share of its residents’ personal income, on interest on past debts, pension contributions, payments to the State of New York for Medicaid, and Police and Correction. As always. Local governments in the rest of New York State also spent more than average on Medicaid payments, but not to nearly the same extent, and spent about average in the other categories were NYC was high. Elementary and secondary education spending, however, was sky-high as a share of personal income in the rest of the state, but below the national average in NYC. As always.
The Winners: Where NYC’s Public Money Went in FY 2005
|It’s Memorial Day weekend as I write this, it’s a beautiful day, and it’s tempting to save some time by just copying my post from last year on the categories of local government expenditures for which New York City and the rest of the state spend more, or less, than the national average. After all, the winners and losers don’t change much from year to year, although the losers sometimes catch up a little in good years (when other interests are sated) and fall behind more in bad years (when victims must be found). But I’ve compiled the data, so I might as well write about it, and the readers could express their gratitude by downloading the spreadsheet linked here (click on the Output tab), printing the two pages, and looking them over. For the less grateful a brief summary table may be found at the bottom of this post, and it shows that New York City spent much more than the U.S. local government average, as a share of its residents’ personal income, on interest on past debts, pension contributions, payments to the State of New York for Medicaid, and Police and Correction. As always. Local governments in the rest of New York State also spent more than average on Medicaid payments, but not to nearly the same extent, and spent about average in the other categories were NYC was high. Elementary and secondary education spending, however, was sky-high as a share of personal income in the rest of the state, but below the national average in NYC. As always.
