The Latest

PLANYC 2030: RATIONING SCARCITY

|

Let’s say we have a public benefit, service, facility or square footage of space that theoretically belongs equally to everyone, cannot be increased at a reasonable cost, and for which the demand far exceeds the supply. How do you decide who gets it? Do you have everyone grab what they can as fast as they can, hoarding and wasting, while those with greater needs are left out in the cold — and disaster is risked if the public benefit, service, facility or space is overwhelmed? Do you use a political process where insiders with power get permits that are then passed on to other insiders, while everyone else, rich and poor, is left to do without? Or should those who have use of the scarce resource have to pay, with the funds used to compensate those who do without it, so that demand equals the supply? New York City has, in fact, has a scarcity of traffic capacity in the Manhattan CBD — and many other areas — on weekdays, and a shortage of electrical generating capacity at peak times on hot days. Today it uses a combination of a grab by those who feel entitled or are willing to sit in traffic (by driving over free bridges or cranking the air conditioning during power shortages) and political power (on-street parking permits) to decide who gets to drive to Manhattan and use electricity on 90 degree afternoons. PLANYC2030 has a different suggestion, and I agree with it.

PLANYC 2030: RATIONING SCARCITY

|

Let’s say we have a public benefit, service, facility or square footage of space that theoretically belongs equally to everyone, cannot be increased at a reasonable cost, and for which the demand far exceeds the supply. How do you decide who gets it? Do you have everyone grab what they can as fast as they can, hoarding and wasting, while those with greater needs are left out in the cold — and disaster is risked if the public benefit, service, facility or space is overwhelmed? Do you use a political process where insiders with power get permits that are then passed on to other insiders, while everyone else, rich and poor, is left to do without? Or should those who have use of the scarce resource have to pay, with the funds used to compensate those who do without it, so that demand equals the supply? New York City has, in fact, has a scarcity of traffic capacity in the Manhattan CBD — and many other areas — on weekdays, and a shortage of electrical generating capacity at peak times on hot days. Today it uses a combination of a grab by those who feel entitled or are willing to sit in traffic (by driving over free bridges or cranking the air conditioning during power shortages) and political power (on-street parking permits) to decide who gets to drive to Manhattan and use electricity on 90 degree afternoons. PLANYC2030 has a different suggestion, and I agree with it.

Rudy – The Phony Federalist

|

Ryan Sager in the NY Sun reported that Rudy Giuliani has announced his opposition to the New Hampshire’s new law creating civil unions for Lesbians & Gay men.

Sager and many bloggers have pointed out that this is the latest change of position and pander to the right by Rudy. But nobody that I have seen has pointed out that this position by Rudy is a sharp contradiction to what he explained was his philosophy only 6 weeks ago on April 10th.

Rudy said then – “One of the great beauties of the kind of government we have, which is a national/federal government, is that we can make — on a broad range of issues — we can make different decisions in different parts of the country,” Mr. Giuliani said. “We have different sensitivities, and at different times we are going to come to different decisions, and I think that is best left up to the states.”

Terry, Kendall, Kevin and Nick: A Tale of One Insurgent and Three Elected Officials In Brooklyn

|

Kendall Stewart, Kevin Parker and Nick Perry are all elected officials in Brooklyn. They are all black democrats. NYC council member Kendall Stewart (45th district) was born on a tiny Caribbean island called Union. I am told that he grew up in both St. Vincent and Trinidad; he is a podiatrist by profession. As far as I know, state senator Kevin Parker was born in the district he represents (21st Senatorial) in East Flatbush/Midwood; he is a college lecturer by profession. State assembly member Nick Perry was born in Jamaica, West Indies; prior to getting elected he worked for the state in some type of civil service capacity (if memory serves me right). I believe that he is a graduate of Brooklyn College (B.A.); he is the eldest of these three electeds. They are all political animals. At different times they have been allied politically; next year they will be fighting like cats and dogs.

PLANYC 2030: The Assumptions

|

Given that I’m not only a certified city planner but also was paid at one point to write parts of similar documents (no, you didn’t read them, no one did), I thought I ought to do Room 8 readers the favor of actually reading through PlanNYC2030, a document whose public discussion has thus far been limited to congestion pricing. This plan follows the similar 1969 Plan for New York City and the 1987 New York Ascendant, each of which was issued at the peak of an economic boom, each of which promised extensive public and publicly-subsidized improvements for city residents, and each of which was immediately followed by a fiscal crisis. I therefore have strong doubts about the value of grand plans, especially those identified for “further study,” and PlanNYC has many of those – often those with a particular group of planning ideologues in favor (I recognize their footprints from the past) who received a tip of the hat here. And then there is the unsaid – which I will try to fill in. The plan, however, also has many real proposals, many good proposals, which I will discuss in other posts. In the end, however, New York in 2030 will come down to something I have come to think about more and more over the years. Money.

PLANYC 2030: The Assumptions

|

Given that I’m not only a certified city planner but also was paid at one point to write parts of similar documents (no, you didn’t read them, no one did), I thought I ought to do Room 8 readers the favor of actually reading through PlanNYC2030, a document whose public discussion has thus far been limited to congestion pricing. This plan follows the similar 1969 Plan for New York City and the 1987 New York Ascendant, each of which was issued at the peak of an economic boom, each of which promised extensive public and publicly-subsidized improvements for city residents, and each of which was immediately followed by a fiscal crisis. I therefore have strong doubts about the value of grand plans, especially those identified for “further study,” and PlanNYC has many of those – often those with a particular group of planning ideologues in favor (I recognize their footprints from the past) who received a tip of the hat here. And then there is the unsaid – which I will try to fill in. The plan, however, also has many real proposals, many good proposals, which I will discuss in other posts. In the end, however, New York in 2030 will come down to something I have come to think about more and more over the years. Money.

PLANYC 2030: The Assumptions

|

Given that I’m not only a certified city planner but also was paid at one point to write parts of similar documents (no, you didn’t read them, no one did), I thought I ought to do Room 8 readers the favor of actually reading through PlanNYC2030, a document whose public discussion has thus far been limited to congestion pricing. This plan follows the similar 1969 Plan for New York City and the 1987 New York Ascendant, each of which was issued at the peak of an economic boom, each of which promised extensive public and publicly-subsidized improvements for city residents, and each of which was immediately followed by a fiscal crisis. I therefore have strong doubts about the value of grand plans, especially those identified for “further study,” and PlanNYC has many of those – often those with a particular group of planning ideologues in favor (I recognize their footprints from the past) who received a tip of the hat here. And then there is the unsaid – which I will try to fill in. The plan, however, also has many real proposals, many good proposals, which I will discuss in other posts. In the end, however, New York in 2030 will come down to something I have come to think about more and more over the years. Money.

PLANYC 2030: The Assumptions

|

Given that I’m not only a certified city planner but also was paid at one point to write parts of similar documents (no, you didn’t read them, no one did), I thought I ought to do Room 8 readers the favor of actually reading through PlanNYC2030, a document whose public discussion has thus far been limited to congestion pricing. This plan follows the similar 1969 Plan for New York City and the 1987 New York Ascendant, each of which was issued at the peak of an economic boom, each of which promised extensive public and publicly-subsidized improvements for city residents, and each of which was immediately followed by a fiscal crisis. I therefore have strong doubts about the value of grand plans, especially those identified for “further study,” and PlanNYC has many of those – often those with a particular group of planning ideologues in favor (I recognize their footprints from the past) who received a tip of the hat here. And then there is the unsaid – which I will try to fill in. The plan, however, also has many real proposals, many good proposals, which I will discuss in other posts. In the end, however, New York in 2030 will come down to something I have come to think about more and more over the years. Money.

PLANYC 2030: The Assumptions

|

Given that I’m not only a certified city planner but also was paid at one point to write parts of similar documents (no, you didn’t read them, no one did), I thought I ought to do Room 8 readers the favor of actually reading through PlanNYC2030, a document whose public discussion has thus far been limited to congestion pricing. This plan follows the similar 1969 Plan for New York City and the 1987 New York Ascendant, each of which was issued at the peak of an economic boom, each of which promised extensive public and publicly-subsidized improvements for city residents, and each of which was immediately followed by a fiscal crisis. I therefore have strong doubts about the value of grand plans, especially those identified for “further study,” and PlanNYC has many of those – often those with a particular group of planning ideologues in favor (I recognize their footprints from the past) who received a tip of the hat here. And then there is the unsaid – which I will try to fill in. The plan, however, also has many real proposals, many good proposals, which I will discuss in other posts. In the end, however, New York in 2030 will come down to something I have come to think about more and more over the years. Money.

PLANYC 2030: The Assumptions

|

Given that I’m not only a certified city planner but also was paid at one point to write parts of similar documents (no, you didn’t read them, no one did), I thought I ought to do Room 8 readers the favor of actually reading through PlanNYC2030, a document whose public discussion has thus far been limited to congestion pricing. This plan follows the similar 1969 Plan for New York City and the 1987 New York Ascendant, each of which was issued at the peak of an economic boom, each of which promised extensive public and publicly-subsidized improvements for city residents, and each of which was immediately followed by a fiscal crisis. I therefore have strong doubts about the value of grand plans, especially those identified for “further study,” and PlanNYC has many of those – often those with a particular group of planning ideologues in favor (I recognize their footprints from the past) who received a tip of the hat here. And then there is the unsaid – which I will try to fill in. The plan, however, also has many real proposals, many good proposals, which I will discuss in other posts. In the end, however, New York in 2030 will come down to something I have come to think about more and more over the years. Money.