The Latest

Richard Brodsky Spouts Infuriating Falsehoods

|

On Capital Confidential, I find this quote: “We’ve racked our brains to find a single example of the use of the education formula to harm an individual municipality…Never before, never before, has a community been singled out for harm."

Read my prior post, and download the spreadsheets attached to this one.

What do you call the decision in the 1995-1996 budget to cut state school aid to low-spending, high needs NYC while increasing it to the rest of the state? What do you call the decision to NYC's share of total state education funding, including STAR, in the wake of 9/11 in exchange for granting the city permission to increase its own debt and taxes?

Wimpy’s State Budget

|

“I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today,” the character Wimpy often said in the Popeye strip. The payment never came. There is much I could praise in the New York State budget recently agreed to, in its precedents and, to a lesser extent, even the way it was adopted, which bad as it was better than in the past. Unlike the Daily News or New York Times, however, I will not write about anything I agree with until my question is answered. Including school aid that is called school aid, back door school aid (STAR), Spitzer's new checks, and all CASH to be spent IN A GIVEN FISCAL YEAR to fund, or to offset local funding for, elementary and secondary education, what was NYC's share of total state spending last year, and what will it be this year? In his initial budget Powerpoint presentation, Governor Spitzer said it was 37% last year and proposed to be 37% next year, with Long Island's share also unchanged at 14.1% (despite a “school aid” shift) because of all the money that area would get from Spitzer's checks. So what was the final result? The Governor and others are going around the state talking about everything else.

Wimpy’s State Budget

|

“I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today,” the character Wimpy often said in the Popeye strip. The payment never came. There is much I could praise in the New York State budget recently agreed to, in its precedents and, to a lesser extent, even the way it was adopted, which bad as it was better than in the past. Unlike the Daily News or New York Times, however, I will not write about anything I agree with until my question is answered. Including school aid that is called school aid, back door school aid (STAR), Spitzer's new checks, and all CASH to be spent IN A GIVEN FISCAL YEAR to fund, or to offset local funding for, elementary and secondary education, what was NYC's share of total state spending last year, and what will it be this year? In his initial budget Powerpoint presentation, Governor Spitzer said it was 37% last year and proposed to be 37% next year, with Long Island's share also unchanged at 14.1% (despite a “school aid” shift) because of all the money that area would get from Spitzer's checks. So what was the final result? The Governor and others are going around the state talking about everything else.

Wimpy’s State Budget

|

“I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today,” the character Wimpy often said in the Popeye strip. The payment never came. There is much I could praise in the New York State budget recently agreed to, in its precedents and, to a lesser extent, even the way it was adopted, which bad as it was better than in the past. Unlike the Daily News or New York Times, however, I will not write about anything I agree with until my question is answered. Including school aid that is called school aid, back door school aid (STAR), Spitzer's new checks, and all CASH to be spent IN A GIVEN FISCAL YEAR to fund, or to offset local funding for, elementary and secondary education, what was NYC's share of total state spending last year, and what will it be this year? In his initial budget Powerpoint presentation, Governor Spitzer said it was 37% last year and proposed to be 37% next year, with Long Island's share also unchanged at 14.1% (despite a “school aid” shift) because of all the money that area would get from Spitzer's checks. So what was the final result? The Governor and others are going around the state talking about everything else.

Wimpy’s State Budget

|

“I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today,” the character Wimpy often said in the Popeye strip. The payment never came. There is much I could praise in the New York State budget recently agreed to, in its precedents and, to a lesser extent, even the way it was adopted, which bad as it was better than in the past. Unlike the Daily News or New York Times, however, I will not write about anything I agree with until my question is answered. Including school aid that is called school aid, back door school aid (STAR), Spitzer's new checks, and all CASH to be spent IN A GIVEN FISCAL YEAR to fund, or to offset local funding for, elementary and secondary education, what was NYC's share of total state spending last year, and what will it be this year? In his initial budget Powerpoint presentation, Governor Spitzer said it was 37% last year and proposed to be 37% next year, with Long Island's share also unchanged at 14.1% (despite a “school aid” shift) because of all the money that area would get from Spitzer's checks. So what was the final result? The Governor and others are going around the state talking about everything else.

Wimpy’s State Budget

|

“I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today,” the character Wimpy often said in the Popeye strip. The payment never came. There is much I could praise in the New York State budget recently agreed to, in its precedents and, to a lesser extent, even the way it was adopted, which bad as it was better than in the past. Unlike the Daily News or New York Times, however, I will not write about anything I agree with until my question is answered. Including school aid that is called school aid, back door school aid (STAR), Spitzer's new checks, and all CASH to be spent IN A GIVEN FISCAL YEAR to fund, or to offset local funding for, elementary and secondary education, what was NYC's share of total state spending last year, and what will it be this year? In his initial budget Powerpoint presentation, Governor Spitzer said it was 37% last year and proposed to be 37% next year, with Long Island's share also unchanged at 14.1% (despite a “school aid” shift) because of all the money that area would get from Spitzer's checks. So what was the final result? The Governor and others are going around the state talking about everything else.

Wimpy’s State Budget

|

“I'd gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today,” the character Wimpy often said in the Popeye strip. The payment never came. There is much I could praise in the New York State budget recently agreed to, in its precedents and, to a lesser extent, even the way it was adopted, which bad as it was better than in the past. Unlike the Daily News or New York Times, however, I will not write about anything I agree with until my question is answered. Including school aid that is called school aid, back door school aid (STAR), Spitzer's new checks, and all CASH to be spent IN A GIVEN FISCAL YEAR to fund, or to offset local funding for, elementary and secondary education, what was NYC's share of total state spending last year, and what will it be this year? In his initial budget Powerpoint presentation, Governor Spitzer said it was 37% last year and proposed to be 37% next year, with Long Island's share also unchanged at 14.1% (despite a “school aid” shift) because of all the money that area would get from Spitzer's checks. So what was the final result? The Governor and others are going around the state talking about everything else.

Who Is The Appeaser?

|

Here’s a challenge for readers of Room 8.

Guess which Presidential candidate is quoted as saying the following soft-headed comments about how the US should deal with Islamic terrorists? Who is sounding like Jimmy Carter or some other appeaser?

We want to do business with them. We would love to have them all wired and part of the Internet buying American products, and then we'll buy their products. And then we'll have the kind of issues we have with China and India, like we used to have with Japan. But those are good issues to have. That's America, that's what America is about."

In the end, he says, victory in the terror war may come down to commerce. "Technology has transformed the world," he told the executives. "Part of the way we're ultimately going to win the war on terror is through that technology. We're going to win the war on terror because, yes, we have to be militarily strong, we have to consider defending ourselves, but ultimately we overcome terrorism when those parts of the world that haven't connected yet connect to the global economy."

Medicaid by State in 2004: Final Data

|

Checking in with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid datamart, I find that all the states have now reported Medicaid information for 2004. In fact a few, including New York State, have already reported data for 2005. Now I am at least able to fully tabulate Medicaid spending by type of service for 2004, and the overall bottom lines are these. New York State’s spending per Medicaid beneficiary was $7,910, 70.4% above the national average and 23.7% higher than the average of surrounding states (PA, NJ, CT, MA, VT). With 6.6% of the nation’s population, New York accounted for 8.5% of its Medicaid beneficiaries, a difference only partially explained by the state’s above average poverty and elderly population. New York State residents accounted for 7.6% of U.S. personal income in 2004, according the Bureau of Economic Analysis, and 8.6% of national earnings in the Health Care and Social Assistance industries. The state, however, accounted for 14.5% of national Medicaid expenditures that year. The details by type of service are in the attached spreadsheet, and are described following the break.

Medicaid by State in 2004: Final Data

|

Checking in with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid datamart, I find that all the states have now reported Medicaid information for 2004. In fact a few, including New York State, have already reported data for 2005. Now I am at least able to fully tabulate Medicaid spending by type of service for 2004, and the overall bottom lines are these. New York State’s spending per Medicaid beneficiary was $7,910, 70.4% above the national average and 23.7% higher than the average of surrounding states (PA, NJ, CT, MA, VT). With 6.6% of the nation’s population, New York accounted for 8.5% of its Medicaid beneficiaries, a difference only partially explained by the state’s above average poverty and elderly population. New York State residents accounted for 7.6% of U.S. personal income in 2004, according the Bureau of Economic Analysis, and 8.6% of national earnings in the Health Care and Social Assistance industries. The state, however, accounted for 14.5% of national Medicaid expenditures that year. The details by type of service are in the attached spreadsheet, and are described following the break.