The Latest

The State Senate on School Aid: Two Deceptions and a Truth

|

In its ongoing effort to preserve an unjust state education finance system, the State Senate must rely on deception, because under no set of consistent principles would New York City receive even the level of state education funding Governor Spitzer has proposed, let alone what it has received in the past. If the State Senate accepts that places whose children have greater needs deserve a higher share of state school aid, New York deserves more. But if argues that better off places deserve more money based on the share of state taxes they pay in, New York City also deserves more. If it argues that those with high taxes deserve more aid, New York City, among the highest-taxed parts of the state, still deserves more. And if it continues to hold that whoever spends the most deserves more state aid, through back-door aid like STAR, then it is hardly adhering to purported Republican principles. In any event, Governor Spitzer hasn’t proposed giving NYC more money as a share of the total; the State Senate is demanding that it receive less money. So to justify the unjustifiable, the State Senate endlessly repeats two deceptions, but last week let slip a truth.

The State Senate on School Aid: Two Deceptions and a Truth

|

In its ongoing effort to preserve an unjust state education finance system, the State Senate must rely on deception, because under no set of consistent principles would New York City receive even the level of state education funding Governor Spitzer has proposed, let alone what it has received in the past. If the State Senate accepts that places whose children have greater needs deserve a higher share of state school aid, New York deserves more. But if argues that better off places deserve more money based on the share of state taxes they pay in, New York City also deserves more. If it argues that those with high taxes deserve more aid, New York City, among the highest-taxed parts of the state, still deserves more. And if it continues to hold that whoever spends the most deserves more state aid, through back-door aid like STAR, then it is hardly adhering to purported Republican principles. In any event, Governor Spitzer hasn’t proposed giving NYC more money as a share of the total; the State Senate is demanding that it receive less money. So to justify the unjustifiable, the State Senate endlessly repeats two deceptions, but last week let slip a truth.

Tax Question for Bloomberg and Quinn

|

In the last recession, the City of New York jacked up property tax rates by 18 percent. Later, Mayor Bloomberg elected to send homeowners a check for $400. Now Speaker Quinn wants to send renters a check as well. Meanwhile, the current four-year financial plan has the city spending $4 billion more than it takes in over the next two fiscal years (wiping out an existing surplus), and then facing a fiscal crisis. Ms. Quinn, if you are Mayor at that time, do you plan to increase property tax rates another 18 to 20 percent, perhaps to be followed by even bigger checks later in your term? Mr. Bloomberg, since that is what you have done, would you recommend that the next Mayor do the same? Should this process of higher rates and special handouts continue indefinately?

Tax Question for Bloomberg and Quinn

|

In the last recession, the City of New York jacked up property tax rates by 18 percent. Later, Mayor Bloomberg elected to send homeowners a check for $400. Now Speaker Quinn wants to send renters a check as well. Meanwhile, the current four-year financial plan has the city spending $4 billion more than it takes in over the next two fiscal years (wiping out an existing surplus), and then facing a fiscal crisis. Ms. Quinn, if you are Mayor at that time, do you plan to increase property tax rates another 18 to 20 percent, perhaps to be followed by even bigger checks later in your term? Mr. Bloomberg, since that is what you have done, would you recommend that the next Mayor do the same? Should this process of higher rates and special handouts continue indefinately?

Tax Question for Bloomberg and Quinn

|

In the last recession, the City of New York jacked up property tax rates by 18 percent. Later, Mayor Bloomberg elected to send homeowners a check for $400. Now Speaker Quinn wants to send renters a check as well. Meanwhile, the current four-year financial plan has the city spending $4 billion more than it takes in over the next two fiscal years (wiping out an existing surplus), and then facing a fiscal crisis. Ms. Quinn, if you are Mayor at that time, do you plan to increase property tax rates another 18 to 20 percent, perhaps to be followed by even bigger checks later in your term? Mr. Bloomberg, since that is what you have done, would you recommend that the next Mayor do the same? Should this process of higher rates and special handouts continue indefinately?

Tax Question for Bloomberg and Quinn

|

In the last recession, the City of New York jacked up property tax rates by 18 percent. Later, Mayor Bloomberg elected to send homeowners a check for $400. Now Speaker Quinn wants to send renters a check as well. Meanwhile, the current four-year financial plan has the city spending $4 billion more than it takes in over the next two fiscal years (wiping out an existing surplus), and then facing a fiscal crisis. Ms. Quinn, if you are Mayor at that time, do you plan to increase property tax rates another 18 to 20 percent, perhaps to be followed by even bigger checks later in your term? Mr. Bloomberg, since that is what you have done, would you recommend that the next Mayor do the same? Should this process of higher rates and special handouts continue indefinately?

Tax Question for Bloomberg and Quinn

|

In the last recession, the City of New York jacked up property tax rates by 18 percent. Later, Mayor Bloomberg elected to send homeowners a check for $400. Now Speaker Quinn wants to send renters a check as well. Meanwhile, the current four-year financial plan has the city spending $4 billion more than it takes in over the next two fiscal years (wiping out an existing surplus), and then facing a fiscal crisis. Ms. Quinn, if you are Mayor at that time, do you plan to increase property tax rates another 18 to 20 percent, perhaps to be followed by even bigger checks later in your term? Mr. Bloomberg, since that is what you have done, would you recommend that the next Mayor do the same? Should this process of higher rates and special handouts continue indefinately?

Tax Question for Bloomberg and Quinn

|

In the last recession, the City of New York jacked up property tax rates by 18 percent. Later, Mayor Bloomberg elected to send homeowners a check for $400. Now Speaker Quinn wants to send renters a check as well. Meanwhile, the current four-year financial plan has the city spending $4 billion more than it takes in over the next two fiscal years (wiping out an existing surplus), and then facing a fiscal crisis. Ms. Quinn, if you are Mayor at that time, do you plan to increase property tax rates another 18 to 20 percent, perhaps to be followed by even bigger checks later in your term? Mr. Bloomberg, since that is what you have done, would you recommend that the next Mayor do the same? Should this process of higher rates and special handouts continue indefinately?

The End of A “Crime” in Park Slope

|

Last Sunday’s New York Times brought what those who like lots of regulations would have to consider “good” news. The Dance Studio of Park Slope, which has operated in open and notorious violation of the New York City zoning resolution since 1981, has lost its lease and will close in October. Yet somehow, the Times does not report the locals celebrating. “In February, after months of finding only spaces that were too small or too expensive or needed extensive renovations, she wrote a letter to the parents of her students appealing for help. Many of the parents, some of whom have sent a series of children to the studio, and some of whom were students there once themselves, responded by canvassing the neighborhood and telling Ms. Kliegel’s story to merchants, in the hope that someone who owns a suitable space would come forward.” What, you mean they don’t see that businesses like hers shouldn’t be allowed? Or perhaps it is only new businesses like hers that shouldn’t be allowed.

The End of A “Crime” in Park Slope

|

Last Sunday’s New York Times brought what those who like lots of regulations would have to consider “good” news. The Dance Studio of Park Slope, which has operated in open and notorious violation of the New York City zoning resolution since 1981, has lost its lease and will close in October. Yet somehow, the Times does not report the locals celebrating. “In February, after months of finding only spaces that were too small or too expensive or needed extensive renovations, she wrote a letter to the parents of her students appealing for help. Many of the parents, some of whom have sent a series of children to the studio, and some of whom were students there once themselves, responded by canvassing the neighborhood and telling Ms. Kliegel’s story to merchants, in the hope that someone who owns a suitable space would come forward.” What, you mean they don’t see that businesses like hers shouldn’t be allowed? Or perhaps it is only new businesses like hers that shouldn’t be allowed.